The Exceptional(?) Mr. Trump

Recent Forum Topics Forums The Public House The Exceptional(?) Mr. Trump

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #80199
    Zooey
    Moderator

    https://www.currentaffairs.org/2018/01/trump-exceptionalism-will-kill-every-last-one-of-your-brain-cells

    “…In narrating Trump’s presidency as totally different from what came before, though, they often end up exaggerating the extent to which Trump’s actions are actually unprecedented (or “unpresidented”). That’s a concerning tendency because it lead to the forgetting of history, but also because it ends up exonerating prior presidents for inexcusable acts. Exhibit A here is the rehabilitation of George W. Bush, who is responsible for an inconceivable amount of death and carnage, but who is increasingly seen as dignified and statesmanlike when compared to Donald Trump. Bush himself encourages that view by occasionally issuing denunciations of Trump’s less defensible outbursts. The more Trump is depicted as an aberrant departure from a sound and principled norm, the better Bush seems. The irony here is that so far, measured on Number Of Illegal Wars That Killed Half A Million Innocent People, Bush is far worse than Trump. And though Trump’s immigration policies are uniquely cruel, much of the rest of Trump’s agenda is simply orthodox Republican politics. Massive tax cuts for corporations, gutting consumer protection, eliminating ObamaCare: I struggle to think of any of Trump’s policies that put him outside the mainstream of the Republican Party….”

    I’d copy the whole thing over here, but it contains a large number of links, and is best read in complete form.

    #80208
    wv
    Participant

    Yeah, i think about that broad issue every single day. How do we compare Presidents? One thing i think about is — How many humans did they kill?

    Obama dropped 26,171 Bombs in 2016 alone (I know you know this).
    How many innocents did he kill(murder)? Will Trump even come close to that number at the end of his first year?

    Then again, Trump’s policies are increasing climate-change and pollution so his policies will lead to more deaths of ALL living things (biosphere), more extinctions, etc. But how do we measure such things?

    I wish we were smart enough to kinda have a running total of all life-forms, US Presidents were responsible for terminating. A scoreboard. Id like to see that.

    bombs:https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jan/09/america-dropped-26171-bombs-2016-obama-legacy

    w
    v

    #80210
    Zooey
    Moderator

    Yeah, I think killing other people may be the thing humans are most creative at. The numbers of methods we have devised of killing each other on a small, individual level, all the way up to the grandest of scales of killing is truly remarkable.

    That and making music, maybe. Humans are pretty creative musically, too.

    #80216
    Billy_T
    Participant

    I would be shocked if the numbers of civilian dead had not seriously increased under Trump, over the already unconscionable and indefensible levels under Obama. I can’t see how it’s even possible that they haven’t.

    Some reasons why:

    The US military is fighting terrorism in 76 countries around the world — here’s where

    1. Trump increased troop levels in Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, and added brand new fronts in Africa and Asia.

    2. He loosened “rules of engagement” protocols for the military (and domestically, for police, border agents, etc.), mocking previous rules as “PC.”

    3. He increased defense spending, with more increases in the pipeline.

    4. His ICE and Justice Department have been far more aggressive in going after migrants — inside and outside the country.

    5. His Justice Department has been far more aggressive in the war on drugs, as well as going after dissidents, especially those who protest against Trump.

    Also, Trump’s bizarre blind eye toward everything Russia made this far more likely:

    Syria and Russia’s latest offensive has killed 177 civilians in 2 weeks

    #80224
    wv
    Participant

    I would be shocked if the numbers of civilian dead had not seriously increased under Trump, over the already unconscionable and indefensible levels under Obama. I can’t see how it’s even possible that they haven’t.

    Some reasons why:

    The US military is fighting terrorism in 76 countries around the world — here’s where

    1. Trump increased troop levels in Iraq, Afghanistan, Syria, and added brand new fronts in Africa and Asia.

    2. He loosened “rules of engagement” protocols for the military (and domestically, for police, border agents, etc.), mocking previous rules as “PC.”

    3. He increased defense spending, with more increases in the pipeline.

    4. His ICE and Justice Department have been far more aggressive in going after migrants — inside and outside the country.

    5. His Justice Department has been far more aggressive in the war on drugs, as well as going after dissidents, especially those who protest against Trump.

    Also, Trump’s bizarre blind eye toward everything Russia made this far more likely:

    Syria and Russia’s latest offensive has killed 177 civilians in 2 weeks

    ==============

    I dunno, BT. I’m not sure any or all of that would come close to 26,000 actual bombs dropped. But, I dunno. I would like to know. But of course as american citizens we are not allowed to know what our CIA/deep-state is really doing and who it is murdering on our behalf.

    Could be Trump is a bigger mass murderer than Obama. Maybe Obama is the bigger mass murderer. Its debatable at this point.

    w
    v

    #80227
    zn
    Moderator

    I dunno, BT. I’m not sure any or all of that would come close to 26,000 actual bombs dropped.

    What’s the number per year. That’s how you measure this cause it’s 1 v. 8.

    8 into 26,000 is 3,250 a year on avg.

    #80233
    Billy_T
    Participant

    ==============

    I dunno, BT. I’m not sure any or all of that would come close to 26,000 actual bombs dropped. But, I dunno. I would like to know. But of course as american citizens we are not allowed to know what our CIA/deep-state is really doing and who it is murdering on our behalf.

    Could be Trump is a bigger mass murderer than Obama. Maybe Obama is the bigger mass murderer. Its debatable at this point.

    w
    v

    WV,

    Trump started with Obama’s baseline. There was no rollback of military action when he took over. From that point, he actually increased troop levels in Iraq, Afghanistan and Syria, as mentioned, and he added dozens of new fronts on the so-called GWOT.

    How could he NOT drop more bombs and kill more civilians? Add to that, his relaxation of military rules of engagement, because he said, repeatedly, that our military had been previously handcuffed due to PC. Translation? Don’t worry about civilians as much as before.

    Throw in a huge shift in Justice Department goals, methods, “enemies,” etc. Gloves off for migrants, minorities, inmates, dissidents, etc.

    Again, I would be completely shocked if the Trump era did not cause a major spike in killings and maimings of the innocent, domestically and internationally. It would defy logic, common sense and everything we know about right-wing ideology, the GOP and Trump himself. And I say this knowing full well that Dem-controlled governments had obscene levels of this as well. Trump is worse. He and the GOP are worse.

    • This reply was modified 6 years, 8 months ago by Billy_T.
    #80235
    Billy_T
    Participant

    btw,

    In the context of all of this talk from Republicans regarding supposed “bias” at the FBI . . .

    I tried to find a Democrat who ran the bureau for any length of time and couldn’t. Hoover, a Republican, ran it from its inception in 1935 until 1972. Subsequent presidents, including Dems, named Republicans to run the agency, with rare exceptions, and none of those exceptions lasted for more than a few months. All longterm directors of the FBI have been Republicans. Same is basically the case for the CIA. I haven’t looked into the NSA and other Intel groups, but I’m betting they’re the same.

    Even when the Dems gain the White House, they tend to name Republicans to run these “deep state” agencies, and the Republicans always name their own. Defense, FBI, CIA . . . etc. . . . are with rare exception controlled by Republicans.

    No credible witness, insider or whistle-blower has ever described “deep state” agencies as left of center. They’re historically “conservative” or even further to the right.

    #80272
    wv
    Participant

    ==============

    I dunno, BT. I’m not sure any or all of that would come close to 26,000 actual bombs dropped. But, I dunno. I would like to know. But of course as american citizens we are not allowed to know what our CIA/deep-state is really doing and who it is murdering on our behalf.

    Could be Trump is a bigger mass murderer than Obama. Maybe Obama is the bigger mass murderer. Its debatable at this point.

    w
    v

    WV,

    Trump started with Obama’s baseline. There was no rollback of military action when he took over. From that point, he actually increased troop levels in Iraq, Afghanistan and Syria, as mentioned, and he added dozens of new fronts on the so-called GWOT.

    How could he NOT drop more bombs and kill more civilians? Add to that, his relaxation of military rules of engagement, because he said, repeatedly, that our military had been previously handcuffed due to PC. Translation? Don’t worry about civilians as much as before.

    Throw in a huge shift in Justice Department goals, methods, “enemies,” etc. Gloves off for migrants, minorities, inmates, dissidents, etc.

    Again, I would be completely shocked if the Trump era did not cause a major spike in killings and maimings of the innocent, domestically and internationally. It would defy logic, common sense and everything we know about right-wing ideology, the GOP and Trump himself. And I say this knowing full well that Dem-controlled governments had obscene levels of this as well. Trump is worse. He and the GOP are worse.

    ================

    Well you may be right, BT, but i havent seen any numbers. I’d like to see some actual stats on how many bombs Trump dropped.

    Granted, i have no idea where the Obama 26-thousand number came from or how accurate it really is 🙂

    And that is essentially my 2017-Continuing-never-ending-complaint — that we dont know WTF our government is actually doing. Layers and layers and layers of lies and lies and more lies. CIA-lies, NSA-lies, Corporate-PR-lies, Pentagon-lies, Presidential-lies, etc, etc, etc.

    This American system jumped the shark a long time ago. We dont control it, and we dont have any say in what it does. We have a tiger by the tail. And we are blindfolded as well.

    PS — …also, fwiw, just because Trump “increases military spending” in this or that area, does necessarily mean he is actually ordering the killing of more actual-humans. There may be some differences between Trump’s body count and Obama/Clintons. We have no idea how many people Obama or Trump are actually killing each and every day. We dont know. I’d like to know. I wish the american people wanted to know. But they dont.

    w
    v

    #80275
    Billy_T
    Participant

    Well you may be right, BT, but i havent seen any numbers. I’d like to see some actual stats on how many bombs Trump dropped.

    Granted, i have no idea where the Obama 26-thousand number came from or how accurate it really is :>)

    And that is essentially my 2017-Continuing-never-ending-complaint — that we dont know WTF our government is actually doing. Layers and layers and layers of lies and lies and more lies. CIA-lies, NSA-lies, Corporate-PR-lies, Pentagon-lies, Presidential-lies, etc, etc, etc.

    This American system jumped the shark a long time ago. We dont control it, and we dont have any say in what it does. We have a tiger by the tail. And we are blindfolded as well.

    PS — …also, fwiw, just because Trump “increases military spending” in this or that area, does necessarily mean he is actually ordering the killing of more actual-humans. There may be some differences between Trump’s body count and Obama/Clintons. We have no idea how many people Obama or Trump are actually killing each and every day. We dont know. I’d like to know. I wish the american people wanted to know. But they dont.

    w
    v

    I definitely agree that we don’t know and we should. Media outlets like The Intercept try to find out, but they can only do so much . . . and I’m guessing . . . I don’t know for sure, of course . . . that they dig at great risk to themselves and their families. I mean, existential risk.

    Neither party should be in power. They shouldn’t be allowed to field dog catchers, IMO. Their history is horrific, on so many fronts, and we’ve discussed a host of them. This routinely triggers the Chomsky, Libertarian Socialist test (CLST) for both of us, I’m guessing:

    Can they justify their holding power? Can they justify holding the temporary lease on power we theoretically gave them — and theoretically should be able to revoke?

    No. They can’t. Not within light years.

    Is it possible to jump the shark after you’ve jumped the shark?

    #80284
    Zooey
    Moderator

    Can they justify their holding power? Can they justify holding the temporary lease on power we theoretically gave them — and theoretically should be able to revoke?

    No. They can’t. Not within light years.

    No, they can’t. They clearly have what Chris Hedges called a “horrifying desire for power and domination, not a commitment to a rational society.”

    #80285
    wv
    Participant

    Can they justify their holding power? Can they justify holding the temporary lease on power we theoretically gave them — and theoretically should be able to revoke?

    No. They can’t. Not within light years.

    No, they can’t. They clearly have what Chris Hedges called a “horrifying desire for power and domination, not a commitment to a rational society.”

    ————————-

    All over the world this American…’thing’ (deep-state, corporotacracy,
    national security state, whatever, blah blah) is doing murderous-secret things. Secret. And. Murderous. Often through intermediaries like Saudi Arabia.

    An empire of blood, built on secret systems.

    Meanwhile, Americans discuss whether football players should be kneeling or not.

    w
    v

Viewing 12 posts - 1 through 12 (of 12 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Comments are closed.