Violence in Sacramento

Recent Forum Topics Forums The Public House Violence in Sacramento

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #47275
    waterfield
    Participant

    http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-california-white-nationalists-sacramento-20160627-snap-story.html

    These are the things that bother me. Even more than rather Hillary is actually a neo -conservative or not.

    There is-across this country-a sweeping movement of racist nationalism that threatens our very fabric. We can all intellectually pontificate here about socialism vs capitalism as we continue to march toward the destruction of the very core of what this country was founded upon.

    At its essence the American people don’t understand and don’t care about the differences in capitalism, socialism, communism, etc. In fact most do not understand the difference in the ideologies. Our only interest is self interest. We have lost our compassion for those who suffer whether it be here or in other parts of the world. We are far too interested in being on the “right side” of political movements.

    In my opinion what we can do is -instead of debating the intellectualism of whether socialism is a better form of government than capitalism or whatever etc-is to look across the street at our neighbor who is less fortunate and suffering and say: what can I do.
    Once we actually begin to actually involve the suffering-instead of using them as a political weapon we just might be able to accomplish something that would bring happiness to a few. I honestly don’t care about winning an intellectual debate in a classroom. If this is a classroom and that means I’m excluded from the fraternity here. So be it.

    • This topic was modified 8 years, 6 months ago by waterfield.
    #47277
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    In my opinion what we can do is –instead of debating the intellectualism of whether socialism is a better form of government than capitalism or whatever etc-is to look across the street at our neighbor who is less fortunate and suffering and say: what can I do.

    Well you can do both things. I know many who DO do both things.

    I appreciate the general sentiment and understand what gave rise to it on this occasion.

    #47286
    Avatar photoBilly_T
    Participant

    In my opinion what we can do is -instead of debating the intellectualism of whether socialism is a better form of government than capitalism or whatever etc-is to look across the street at our neighbor who is less fortunate and suffering and say: what can I do.

    Waterfield,

    One of the biggest reasons for my passionate belief in real socialism replacing our current system is just that. That person across the street who suffers. Or anyone suffering anywhere. I see the vast majority of the suffering as due to capitalism. And from my POV, it’s not a matter of “unbridled capitalism.” It’s not something we can tame or reform. It’s the thing itself. It’s the way it unleashed competitive laws of motion on the world that weren’t there before it, how it destroyed local markets and local ways of life in order to unify all markets under one thumb. It did this violently when it rose. It still uses violence today, but, because it’s already conquered nearly everything, we don’t see that as blatantly as before. But its effects never go away. No economic system prior to it ever caused so much widespread suffering, as no previous economic system was inherently imperialistic like capitalism. No previous system ever had its imperatives to Grow or Die . . . so that it must take over time and space — the future and all geography, near and far.

    Boiled down: I think real socialism is the answer. The real deal. Which means the people own the means of production directly, not through proxies like political parties. The entire economy is fully democratic, with everyone having an equal say, an equal voice, an equal share. No bosses. No gods, no masters. We are all co-owners. No employees. No employers.

    No economic system in which everyone has an equal say, an equal share, an equal stake, is going to allow the kind of suffering you speak of. It will have its own problems, conflicts, make its own set of errors. But with the end of the class system, with all of the old hierarchies toppled, it’s not going to be a matter of haves and have-nots anymore. That’s the road to a better world, and it’s a “pragmatic” road, too.

    • This reply was modified 8 years, 6 months ago by Avatar photoBilly_T.
    #47288
    Avatar photoBilly_T
    Participant

    Of course, a general discussion of systems doesn’t preclude discussions of specifics under the current regime. As ZN mentions, we can do both/and.

    But, IMO, it’s very important to zoom out, think in terms of systems, and ultimate goals. Attacking just the issues, without some kind of overall “prize” in mind, some kind of horizon to aspire to . . . . can lead to a very bad sort of “pragmatics.” A “crackpot realism” that eschews taking any chances, doing anything that might appear out of the box and upset people. That kind of pragmatics often seems far more worried about appearances, and “What will people say!!” than actually ending suffering. It seeks the appearance of being “sensible” above concrete, effective actions that benefit the many.

    That’s my take, anyway.

    • This reply was modified 8 years, 6 months ago by Avatar photoBilly_T.
    #47290
    Avatar photowv
    Participant

    http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-california-white-nationalists-sacramento-20160627-snap-story.html

    These are the things that bother me. Even more than rather Hillary is actually a neo -conservative or not.

    There is-across this country-a sweeping movement of racist nationalism that threatens our very fabric. We can all intellectually pontificate here about socialism vs capitalism as we continue to march toward the destruction of the very core of what this country was founded upon.

    At its essence the American people don’t understand and don’t care about the differences in capitalism, socialism, communism, etc. In fact most do not understand the difference in the ideologies. Our only interest is self interest. We have lost our compassion for those who suffer whether it be here or in other parts of the world. We are far too interested in being on the “right side” of political movements.

    In my opinion what we can do is -instead of debating the intellectualism of whether socialism is a better form of government than capitalism or whatever etc-is to look across the street at our neighbor who is less fortunate and suffering and say: what can I do.
    Once we actually begin to actually involve the suffering-instead of using them as a political weapon we just might be able to accomplish something that would bring happiness to a few. I honestly don’t care about winning an intellectual debate in a classroom. If this is a classroom and that means I’m excluded from the fraternity here. So be it.

    ===================

    Well, no-one is going to argue against helping real people in real ways. Sure, everyone should do that on a local level. No argument.

    People around here are doing things for the flood victims for example.

    But man, its often impossible to simply divorce good-works from politics, Waterfield. I mean there is a relationship between the politics/ideologies of the Clintons/Trumps/Reagans/Bushes and what happens on the local level, in the real world.

    I dont care about ‘winning an intellectual debate’ either, fwiw. But i have opinions, and this is where i often spout them.

    You are not excluded from the class-room here, btw. Your political views are just in the minority here. Like bnw’s. Its no big thing, right. Savor it 🙂

    w
    v

    #47291
    Avatar photoBilly_T
    Participant

    You are not excluded from the class-room here, btw. Your political views are just in the minority here. Like bnw’s. Its no big thing, right. Savor it 🙂

    I second this. I like reading your stuff, Waterfield. We don’t often agree, but you’re a good egg.

    You also can take some solace in the fact that your views are often in the mainstream, and that in many circles, you likely sit with the majority. I’ve made my peace with my own minority status, with the political and philosophical journey I’ve been on as a minority’s vision quest. It can feel kinda lonely at times, but I deal with that. It’s good to find sympathetic ears from time to time.

Viewing 6 posts - 1 through 6 (of 6 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Comments are closed.