Recent Forum Topics › Forums › The Rams Huddle › the offense is bad because of….?
- This topic has 14 replies, 6 voices, and was last updated 9 years ago by zn.
-
AuthorPosts
-
November 27, 2015 at 8:06 am #34750znModerator
Fisher
Cignetti
Young and now injured OL
QB(s)
All of the above.
Can it improve or is it doomed?
..
November 27, 2015 at 8:42 am #34751AgamemnonParticipantAll of the above, plus the WRs and TEs, and the stupid refs. š
It all works together. The line will get healthier and older. The pass catchers can be improved in the draft. They need to get Foles fixed. We need a real passing game. The coaches will have to figure out something, pass or die. We will be ok next year. It is too much to fix this year. imo
Cut Cook. Give his targets to Quick. Quick can play better TE than Cook anyway.
November 27, 2015 at 9:36 am #34755wvParticipantFisher
Cignetti
Young and now injured OL
QB(s)
All of the above.
Can it improve or is it doomed?Thats the question of the year.
Not the entire offense, just the PASS Offense.I just dont know.
Greg Robinson is a problem for one thing.
But is he a problem because he’s young? Or
is he a problem because he aint got the
balance/talent to be an NFL LT ? I dunno.Foles is obviously a mess. But why,
and can he recover and fit in this offense?
I dunno.The injuries are obviously a major problem
and the offense looked ok against Seattle in
the first game — but then there was plenty of
bad offense before the rash of injuries.It wont get fixed this year, and they
might only win a game or two more.The offseason will be interesting.
w
vNovember 27, 2015 at 1:13 pm #34761nittany ramModeratorThe offseason will be interesting.
w
vThis may be the most interesting offseason in 20 years.
You have all the questions surrounding the QB and the pass offense in general. There are also tough personnel decisions to be made on defense – the contracts of many good players will be up. Can’t resign them all. Which means this will be another critical draft for the defense as well as the offense.
Then, of course, there’s the move…
November 27, 2015 at 1:18 pm #34762wvParticipantThe offseason will be interesting.
w
vThis may be the most interesting offseason in 20 years.
You have all the questions surrounding the QB and the pass offense in general. There are also tough personnel decisions to be made on defense ā the contracts of many good players will be up. Canāt resign them all. Which means this will be another critical draft for the defense as well as the offense.
Then, of course, thereās the moveā¦
Yeah. We cant even be totally sure Fisher
will be here next year.Free agency will be fascinating. They
‘could’ get a lot of cap space, i would think,
by jettisoning Chris Long, Saffold and Cook.
Could they find better/healthier replacements
in free agency?I think its impossible to say if Cignetti
is a good or bad OC at this point. Too soon.w
vNovember 27, 2015 at 1:37 pm #34764znModerator. They
ācouldā get a lot of cap space, i would think,
by jettisoning Chris Long, Saffold and Cook.I really doubt they jettison Long. (And probably not Saffold either).
And…they do have a lot of cap space, actually.
Cook, I will jettison myself. So look for that. I will step in immediately the exact second the season ends.
.
November 27, 2015 at 1:52 pm #34769znModeratorfrom off the net
==
-X-
I’d just like to point out something here. Call it a refresher course in what can happen to a better than average QB who finds himself introducing himself to new faces on the O-line throughout the season.
Marc Bulger was among the fastest QBs to reach 10,000 yards passing early in his career when he had some decent weapons and a good O-line. I think it was the third fastest in NFL history. Then by the time 2007 rolled around, he was forced to play behind Orlando Pace, Alex Barron, Mark Setterstrom, Andy McCollum, Brett Romberg, Dustin Fry, Millford Brown, Claude Terrel, Todd Steussie, Nick Lecky, Adam Goldberg, Brandon Gorin and Rob Petitti. 13 different offensive linemen who rotated around the line never really manning one position for an entire season.
WHILE throwing to Torry Holt and Isaac Bruce for most of the season and having Steven Jackson in the backfield (for 12 games), that team won 3 games. Partly because the defense was for crap. 31st in the league in points allowed.
So when we see a new QB (two, actually) executing plays from a new OC, and trying to man-up behind a line where we lost our starting RG, LG, and RT, while rotating guys in all three spots and putting centers out at RT, and throwing to names who aren’t really popular around the league, what is it exactly that we expect? Honestly, we should *expect* to get our asses handed to us every week. And yet, this team has a 2 point score differential and a top 10 defense ANYWAY. So when we lose, what exactly is it that you think we should have done with that kind of wrecked O-line led by a new QB taking direction from a new OC? Win anyway? Convincingly? Why? I just showed you what could happen with two HOF receivers, a great RB, and a better than average (good) QB playing behind an injury plagued O-line. We should do more with worse personnel? Well, actually we are. And it’s a testament to the kind of defense we have that can weather an offense crap-storm like that and keep this team in the game for 4 quarters.
Blame Fisher if you want, but he didn’t put on a Kathy Bates mask and go out and hobble his own O-linemen with a 5-pound sledge.
crap. Happens.
November 27, 2015 at 4:43 pm #34776PA RamParticipantLack of consistent players on the o-line is a major factor, obviously.
But there’s a lot going on here. It can’t be just ONE thing.
Poor QB play? Check.
Poor o-line play? Check.
Poor coaching? Check.
Injuries? Check.
It’s many things. And there is no way it can be fixed this year. It’s another lost season.
Back to the drawing board.
What I WOULD do though is not let this season fall into a season that grinds Gurley to dust. Save him. Yes–let him run but I’d ease up on carries per game. It’s useless this year anyway.
"Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away. " Philip K. Dick
November 27, 2015 at 5:26 pm #34778wvParticipantLack of consistent players on the o-line is a major factor, obviously.
But thereās a lot going on here. It canāt be just ONE thing.
I dunno how much of this is the OLine Injuries.
It may very well be that this team could
have won Ten games if the OLine had stayed healthy
and gelled. I dunno. Possible. I’m totally open
to that possibility that the “OLine Injury Theory” (OLIT)
is the major or total cause of this year’s
Fiasco (TYF)But, I dunno.
One of the factors that I see, that has nothing
to do with injuries is Greg Robinson. He
has not been good. Will he ever be? I dunno.Would Foles have been good enough had he not
be beaten up so much? I dunno. Maybe. But man,
he sure does look ‘slow’ out there.The Receivers have been dropping balls
in key situations — why ?Penalties.
Missed extra points, field goals.
Its a spectacle.
w
vNovember 27, 2015 at 6:14 pm #34780PA RamParticipantLack of consistent players on the o-line is a major factor, obviously.
But thereās a lot going on here. It canāt be just ONE thing.
I dunno how much of this is the OLine Injuries.
It may very well be that this team could
have won Ten games if the OLine had stayed healthy
and gelled. I dunno. Possible. Iām totally open
to that possibility that the āOLine Injury Theoryā (OLIT)
is the major or total cause of this yearās
Fiasco (TYF)But, I dunno.
One of the factors that I see, that has nothing
to do with injuries is Greg Robinson. He
has not been good. Will he ever be? I dunno.Would Foles have been good enough had he not
be beaten up so much? I dunno. Maybe. But man,
he sure does look āslowā out there.The Receivers have been dropping balls
in key situations ā why ?Penalties.
Missed extra points, field goals.
Its a spectacle.
w
vI do think that the injuries had some effect because constant shuffling just can’t be good. And I can see where they could have won maybe one or two more games. What I don’t want to hear as an excuse from Fisher are the “rookies-on-the-line” excuse. That’s his doing. And besides–first game of the season New England started THREE rookies and did just fine.
But yes–there are many issues. Do QBs on this team just suffer from battered QB syndrome? Maybe that’s part of it but there are cases when they also take the fault for some sacks. That’s lack of awareness.
The dropped balls?
Well—they drafted these guys or signed them as free agents. So many things on this team seem like mental lapses–and I point directly at a guy like Cook or Greg Robinson. Does this team consider the “mental” component when selecting players or is it all about athleticism?
I fully expect Fisher to get another year–and I’m okay with that. But he has run out of excuses as far as I’m concerned. It’s his fifth year. Put up or shut up. I don’t care who goes down. Deal with it. He’s been given the benefit of the doubt for four years. That’s plenty.
I feel that he may even bind OCs to his own version of what an offense is allowed to do and that is pretty predictable.
He needs to rethink some things or move on to the next team with his mediocre approach to football.
"Reality is that which, when you stop believing in it, doesn't go away. " Philip K. Dick
November 27, 2015 at 6:33 pm #34783wvParticipant… Put up or shut up. I donāt care who goes down. Deal with it. Heās been given the benefit of the doubt for four years. Thatās plenty.
I feel that he may even bind OCs to his own version of what an offense is allowed to do and that is pretty predictable.
He needs to rethink some things or move on to the next team with his mediocre approach to football.Well if your main point is that you are
Mad As Hell And Youre Not Going To Take It Anymore —Then I’m with ya.
Let us now, go to the window…
w
vNovember 27, 2015 at 7:06 pm #34784Eternal RamnationParticipantI was listening to a Martz interview from a couple of weeks back. Remember when he started it seemed like he had pro-bowl QB’s coming out his ears?Very QB friendly system. The Center calls the protection which predetermines the hot read. If the center was wrong they just lived with it.Almost everyone else puts all that on the QB so when they struggle with reads it slows and stresses existing problems like accuracy and timing. IMO this is on Fisher. His offenses all look the same with Titans and the Rams even on the rare exception they’ve been good it came down to extraordinary individual skills McNair, George , Johnson. An improved OL would certainly help but so far the OL has deteriorated each season for 4 seasons so I see no reason to believe Fisher will be successful in a 5th or 6th attemp.
November 28, 2015 at 1:08 am #34788znModeratorAn improved OL would certainly help but so far the OL has deteriorated each season for 4 seasons so I see no reason to believe Fisher will be successful in a 5th or 6th attemp.
See I disagree with that. There are long spates where the Fisher Rams OL was fine and played well—demonstrably so, numbers back this. But then those spates of playing well are surrounded by periods where they have multiple OL injuries.
Anyway it wasn’t majorly injured and so played well in the 2nd half of 2012 and most of 2013.
2015 is different. That’s just a young OL.
I trust these guys—Fisher and Boudreau–to build good lines because they have with the Rams and they both did before the Rams, many times each.
It’s just that a young inexperienced OL is going to struggle at first.
November 28, 2015 at 7:10 am #34789Eternal RamnationParticipantAn improved OL would certainly help but so far the OL has deteriorated each season for 4 seasons so I see no reason to believe Fisher will be successful in a 5th or 6th attemp.
See I disagree with that. There are long spates where the Fisher Rams OL was fine and played wellādemonstrably so, numbers back this. But then those spates of playing well are surrounded by periods where they have multiple OL injuries.
Anyway it wasnāt majorly injured and so played well in the 2nd half of 2012 and most of 2013.
2015 is different. Thatās just a young OL.
I trust these guysāFisher and Boudreauāto build good lines because they have with the Rams and they both did before the Rams, many times each.
Itās just that a young inexperienced OL is going to struggle at first.
We just use different numbers ZN. Mine aren’t stats I simplify down to this, the higher the quantity of Fisher acquired Boudreau trained lineman the worse the quality has been. Yes they were much better in 12′ and some of 13′ dropped way off in 14 and now in the present hopefully having hit bottom this is a 100% Fisher owned OL .He owns the strategy behind the build, his idea to draft and play players that played lots and lots of games in their collegiate careers and the resulting record is his to. I would love for the graph to climb North for a decade but in reality it has been a steady downward trend for 4 years.
November 28, 2015 at 9:37 am #34790znModeratorWe just use different numbers ZN. Mine arenāt stats I simplify down to this, the higher the quantity of Fisher acquired Boudreau trained lineman the worse the quality has been.
I look at performance when they’re not suffering multiple injuries. For example the 2nd half of 2012. In that spate of 8 games, they allowed a 4% sack percentage (the lowest for any Rams qb since the mid 80s). They got Jackson 4.3 a carry. They took on SF at its strongest and went 1-0-1. In fact in those 8 games they played 5 games against top 12 defense, and ended up going 4-3-1, and that’s with nothing at receiver but Amendola.
You just don’t do that if your OL is bad.
And it is true that you can go through the past 20 years and see top lines put together by Boudreau, and also Fisher.
What’s interesting about the 2012 group is that it included players who never did anything before the Rams, and haven’t done anything since the Rams, like Turner and Richardson.
So yes I trust them and yes the numbers back that.
That of course just means we see it differently and may be looking at different things.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.