I would have put Sehorn on that list.
Yeah me too.
And, Eric Hill.
I also wouldn’t have put Finnegan on it or at least not that high. I didn’t like his bush league antics but in 2012 he played effectively. It’s after the injuries that his play declined. A guy can’t help injuries. That was the same story with Jake Long and Scott Wells.
I agree. I considered saying something along the same lines about Finnegan. He was effective his first year, and brought a toughness to the D that it needed. Yeah, he turned out to be a pain in the butt, and he deteriorated after that first year, but he wasn’t the complete mess from the start that other guys on that list were.