Forum Replies Created

Viewing 30 posts - 37,831 through 37,860 (of 47,064 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: harsh eye on both candidates #50308
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Ok, but i can tell you I bet no-one on this board
    thinks you were being all “MOD-heavy” in any way. This aint got
    nuthin to do with Mod or Not-Mod.

    I get PMS all the time, and I have to take a break from
    pol-threads from time to time. So, if you need to take a break for a while, fine,
    but there’s no need to make it permanent.

    I mean dont take any blood oaths or anything. Dont go
    and join the Night Watch.

    w
    v

    I know. I didnt get any vibe that I was seen as mod-heavy. This was all me, responding to me. It didn’t have nuthin to do with what others might think. I was thinking, I am a little edgy when I post on this election stuff…and, that means (in my own eyes) that I am not as effective as a mod, who needs to be more above it all. Matter of degree. This is just how I see it. And I have no issues with the other mods at all. But to me, a mod is Dudley Do-Rright. As an election issue poster I was channeling some Cartman.

    So I promise. No Night Watch. No oaths. Just me on a minor little thing, trying to do a minor little version of the right thing.

    Though I will post articles about everything. Just not engage in debate. I mean it’s not fair. I always win. So, I should be more restrained.

    in reply to: 8/3-8/5 … Camp reports #50305
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Good work with posting all the reports and stuff, zn.

    Tx, to all. I will mention Isiah too, for his live camp reports.

    It’s easy n fun, like the zine was back in the day.

    Later I will post my own camp report. It includes things like this: “Is Coach Waufle more Nietzschean or Hegelian? Well if you watch him during drills…”

    in reply to: harsh eye on both candidates #50303
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    In the real world, I have to deal with enough of that as is. In my social/work world, I am surrounded by both Clinton nazis who don’t get or tolerate dissent, and Sanders nazis who don’t get or tolerate “selling out.” Well a pox on both their houses. In this election, I am both a dissenter and a sell out. Which only means I can’t talk about it with anyone cause they are all diehards. I nod and smile.

    ————-
    Thats all well and good, but other than W, i cant think of anyone on this
    board who would care whether you did the “lesser evil” thing or the “fuck the Duplicats” thing. No-one here has ever called you a sell-out or a dissenter, etc. People have just shared what ‘they’ are gonna do. Thats how ive seen it, anyway. I havent seen anybody trying to ‘persuade’ anybody about how to vote — cept, W. (and we all like W, so even that dont matter)

    w
    v

    I know. I was just getting in some extra-curricular griping. That wasn’t supposed to be a comment on the posters here. I was suggesting that my real-world demeanor was spilling over, and that in recognition of that, I wasn’t going to get into election discussions. I didn’t “blame” that on anyone but me.

    in reply to: 8/3-8/5 … Camp reports #50302
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Merlin: 8/5 camp report

    SOME FOLLOW-UP

    We were discussing in our section how IF you were to take the numbers off the QBs and watch them the guy you would think is the rookie is Mannion. Goff is very measured and confident and in most of his snaps smooth with his decision making and of the three the only one who routinely makes the time to look downfield; if a nice pass goes mid to further range it’s usually Goff. The occasional INT would plague the others I think IF they were looking downfield and across the middle more often, because this defense is fast and knows what they are doing.

    In yesterday’s practice there were probably 3x or so where I chuckled and said something along the lines of “welcome to the NFL rookie.” Other than that you just wouldn’t know he was a rook based on his demeanor. I think he is going to make the doubters look pretty silly, personally. And I think the team knows it too, not just the offense.

    My guess is the kid will light Dallas up by the time they play that game. And he’ll probably make a mistake or two that will be trotted out there on social media but that’s ok. I just don’t see any way he’s not running this offense soon as the starter, whether it’s game 1 or game 3 or so.

    If game 1 in SF was tomorrow Keenum would start, because he has the offense down and has all the confidence of the staff in managing it. But I do not see some big dropoff personally, where Goff looks lost or behind. What I see personally is a kid who seems to know the offense quite well for a rookie who has seen 5 camp practices, and who offers so much more upside that there is absolutely no reason to think he won’t be the best option a month from now.

    IMO the reason most top 5 QBs start soon is because teams that pick early do not have holdover starters at QB of the quality required to give them a better chance to win. So inevitably those top 5 picks end up being the clear best chance to win for the team and they play. Looking at Goff, the kid seems confident and like he’s making daily strides. Keenum is a good guy and a solid backup type QB, but he is not Brett Favre. He is not a QB of the caliber required to hold Goff on the bench.

    ***

    Higbee — in the drills and scrimmage every time the ball comes his way he reels it in smooth, and he’s so big defenses are gonna have to tee off on him to make him feel hits. Of all the players yesterday outside of Gurley and Tavon he was the one that most impressed me.

    in reply to: Court strikes down North Carolina voter ID law #50297
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    in reply to: camp reports for 8/2 #50295
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    ramsman34

    SOME FOLLOW-UP

    Goff looked much sharper day 3 and his clock looked to have sped up a bit relative to the first 2 practices. That said, Keenum hasn’t looked bad at all. It is his utter lack of arm strength that gets me. I came away after Tuesday’s practiced certain Goff would claim the staring roll. More will be revealed today and throughout the preseason. Unless one of them totally craps the bed, I can see Fisher waiting to name a starter for game one as early as after preseason game 3, or as late as the week of practice prior to the opener.

    in reply to: harsh eye on both candidates #50294
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Ooh, a challenge. Let’s see if we can bait zn into participating on this forum…

    Oh I will participate in the forum. Just not on election stuff. There are plenty of other topics (example: how a bad movie season influences garden design.)

    For example, I am sure to speak up whenever someone flagrantly, with malicious intentions, misreads a post. And I bring hell with me.

    in reply to: harsh eye on both candidates #50292
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Besides, I;m cranky.

    I;ve come to a little conclusion. I can’t mod politics discussions AND participate. So I won’t participate. This year is different—this year, a formerly united left (which is what we had on the original huddle public board) is now divided. That calls for a different kind of moderating. I personally can’t do that and then also jump in with my cranky 2 cents. So I will save my own 2 cents for other topics. I am not complaining btw, just making what I think is the best choice as a mod.

    In the real world, I have to deal with enough of that as is. In my social/work world, I am surrounded by both Clinton nazis who don’t get or tolerate dissent, and Sanders nazis who don’t get or tolerate “selling out.” Well a pox on both their houses. In this election, I am both a dissenter and a sell out. Which only means I can’t talk about it with anyone cause they are all diehards. I nod and smile.

    in reply to: ESPN/Football Outsiders rank Rams 5th In Under-25 Talent #50288
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Rams have only 18 players over 25, one over 30

    This is a direct result of 2 things IMO.

    1. They have only 6 guys on the roster from before 2012 (Quinn, Sims, Saffold, Barnes, Kendricks, Reynolds).

    2. They got out of the high-end FA market. It didn’t help that of their 4 biggest contracts for FAs, 3 got massively injured (Finnegan, Long, Wells) and 1 (Cook) wasn’t worth the money. They do better in the lower FA market (Hayes, Reynolds, Fairley, Ayers). IMO one aspect of this is that buying expensive FAs now takes future cap space away for when they have to re-up Donald and Goff.

    in reply to: K.Greene in the hall #50286
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Kevin Greene first soared in the ‘Eagle’ defense the Rams designed for him

    http://www.ocregister.com/articles/greene-724864-robinson-defense.html%5B/quote%5D

    It’s almost absurd to think about it now, what with Kevin Greene donning the iconic gold jacket signifying membership into Pro Football Hall of Fame and his bust soon on display in Canton. But back in the mid 1980s, the rangy fifth-round pick from Auburn was so starved for playing time he was literally begging then-Los Angeles Rams coach John Robinson for a chance to play.

    Never the wallflower type, Greene kept showing up in Robinson’s office asking what he needed to do to get on the field.

    Over and over and over.

    “At the time, he threatened to send my butt back to Alabama,” Greene recalled.

    That didn’t stop Greene, the son of military man and himself a Captain in the Army Reserves.

    “I just kept knocking on the door.” he said.

    Robinson feigned annoyance, but deep down he couldn’t help admire the nerve, confidence and hunger of the longshot linebacker.

    “He was just so eager,” Robinson remembered. “He was, good gosh, just the epitome of a guy trying to figure out a way to get better and become a productive player.”

    But there was a problem. In Robinson and defensive coordinator Fritz Shurmur’s traditional 3-4 scheme at the time, outside linebackers were asked to rush the passer and drop back into pass coverage.

    “He could rush the passer,” Robinson said. “But he couldn’t pass cover for crap.”

    He also wasn’t strong enough to hold up against offensive tackles as a traditional 3-4 defensive end. So a position switch wasn’t an option.

    Which explains why Greene didn’t make a single start over his first three years in the NFL.

    Fortunately for Greene – although not so much for the Rams – the defense was so putrid getting pressure on the quarterback in 1987 that Robinson and Shurmur had to cook up something different to fix it.

    Enter an innovative new defense, and the key that turned an average outside linebacker into a dominant pass rusher.

    “Fritz Shurmur, our defensive coordinator, saw something in me and put together a defense for me,” Greene said.

    Or so he was about to find out. Because the day Robinson called Greene into his office to let him know about the change, Greene was so worried the meeting was to tell him he was getting cut he later said he darn near wet his britches.

    Only to learn Robinson and Shurmur were designing a defense to highlight his skill set.

    “Changed my career,” Greene said.

    Essentially, Robinson and Shurmur eliminated Greene’s pass coverage responsibilities and turned him into a full-time edge pass rusher operating out of formations designed to drive quarterbacks batty.

    At its core, the Eagle defense was about speed and chaos. And in its essence, it was the birthplace of the zone blitz, with pressure coming from linebackers, safeties and cornerbacks.

    The goal was to take advantage of Greene’s speed and rush instincts and create confusion for opposing quarterbacks, who often gazed across the line of scrimmage to see two outside linebackers stacked over the tight end and a “nose backer” lined up a yard behind the line of scrimmage – only to pop up as a standup linebacker.

    So sure of the new scheme and Greene’s fit in it, Robinson promptly declared Greene would lead the league in sacks the following season.

    “I didn’t know crap about what I was talking about,” Robinson said, laughing. “But I had a feeling he’d be good at it.”

    And Greene was ready to break loose.

    “I paid my dues at that time and seasoned a little bit, and I was really chomping at the bit to go,” he said.

    Greene didn’t lead the league in sacks like Robinson predicted – but he came close. His 16.5 sacks in 1988 were second behind Eagles defensive end Reggie White’s 20 .

    A star was born.

    “I was able to be productive in that defense, so yes, it definitely helped me,” Greene said.

    As Robinson recalls, a couple of things lined up perfectly for Greene.

    “We put the defense in, and Jackie Slater was his opponent all the time.” Robinson said.

    That would be eventual Hall of Fame left tackler Jackie Slater, who became Greene’s daily practice nemesis. The two would consistently square off in memorable match ups, with the older, wiser, more seasoned Slater usually getting the best of Greene.

    “I mean, it was really competitive,” Robinson said. “And I don’t know if they were enemies or friends but they worked hard.

    “I can remember Jackie just crushing Kevin and Kevin jumping up and saying: ‘Thank you Jackie I needed that. Now let’s do it again.’ That’s how he was, and he got to be really, really good.”

    Greene followed up his 16.5 sacks in 1988 with 16.5 in 1989 and 13 in 1990 while emerging as one of the league’s best pass rushers.

    “It was really nice to see him blossom,” Robinson said. “He wanted it so badly, and was willing to stick at it and work out of it.

    But in 1991, Robinson hired Buddy Ryan disciple Jeff Fisher as his new defensive coordinator – yes, the Rams current head coach – and Fisher moved away from the 3-4 defense in favor of the 4-3 scheme. Greene was moved from outside linebacker to defensive end as a result, and his sacks plummeted to three.

    Robinson and his entire coaching staff got cleared out at the end of the season – replaced by Chuck Knox – and while Greene’s sack total shot up to 10 playing outside linebacker in the 4-3, the fit just wasn’t right.

    Greene hit free agency after the 1992 season, and went looking for a team with a 3-4 defense. He eventually landed in Pittsburgh, where he reclaimed his pass rushing status under Dick LeBeau while racking up 36.5 sacks over the next three seasons.

    “His career really took off there,” said Robinson.

    Greene would play 15 years total – including stints with the Panthers and 49ers – before retiring in 1999 with 160 career sacks, which ranks third in NFL history.

    And now he’s in the Hall of Fame.

    Looking back, who knows what would have happened had Robinson and Shurmur not needed to figure out a way to get to the quarterback as desperately as they did in 1988. Or had the foresight to scrap conventional wisdom in pursuit of creating a scheme to fit a unique skill set like Greene’s.

    “And really, that’s what coaching is all about,” Robinson said. “Your job is to bring out the best in players. Help make a player. And if there is greatness, try to find it. Sometimes it isn’t obvious, you have to dig a little bit.

    “And whether it’s the head coach or coordinator you have to give the guy the scheme that brings it out in him. A Bill Walsh bringing out the skills of Joe Montana. Or any of those situations where the coach and the player together create a successful environment. It’s one of the ultimate aspects of being a coach.”

    And in this case, it turned a decent outside linebacker into an eventual Hall of Famer.

    in reply to: ESPN/Football Outsiders rank Rams 5th In Under-25 Talent #50285
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Youth movement: Rams have only 18 players over 25, one over 30

    steve Dilbeck

    http://www.espn.com/blog/st-louis-rams/post/_/id/29943/youth-movement-rams-have-18-players-over-25-and-one-over-30-on-roster

    IRVINE, Calif. — Ah, youth. So fleeting, so exciting, so very unpredictable.

    The Rams were one of the league’s youngest team’s last season and went 7-9.

    They had the worst passing game in the NFL and are now expected to turn the offense over to 21-year-old quarterback Jared Goff. Their star player is 22-year-old running back Todd Gurley. Their defensive standout is a comparative old man, 25-year-old tackle Aaron Donald.

    Los Angeles’ William Hayes
    At 31, defensive end William Hayes qualifies as a grizzled veteran on the Rams.
    Indeed, on their roster they have exactly one player over 30. Starting defensive end William Hayes is a team aberration, sliding in at age 31.

    In ESPN’s annual age rankings for every NFL team released this week, the Rams came in as the league’s fifth youngest team. That’s actually an uptick from last year when this massive team was in full bloom and they were at No. 3.

    But on their 89-man roster this season, they have only 18 players over the age of 25. Half of those, however, are expected to start. That still leaves plenty of young starters, who for the most part, will be backed up by even younger players.

    So it may not be peach fuzz all around, but youth clearly still abides as the Rams try to win over their new Los Angeles fan base.

    All that youth began to show promise last season. The Rams won three of their last four games, losing the season finale to the 49ers in San Francisco in overtime. Which is where they open the regular season next month.

    If youth is to be served, and the Rams are going to make that next step as a developing team, they need it to be now.

    in reply to: 8/3-8/5 … Camp reports #50284
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Merlin

    8/5 camp report

    Ok so got back late after a post-practice stop that was in truth a derailment at Hooters. Had a great time, so from the top I gotta give the Rams org props on setting up a really fine venue. Picked up some gear for the kids, looked around and wished there was a beer stand, but learned later in practice why there is no beer stand which I’ll cover in a moment.

    First off watched the QBs doing all manner of basic drills. Handoffs, footwork, even making throws over the crossbar to each other I suppose to ensure the right arc is there I don’t know. Got bored though, and will only note what everyone knows, which is that Keenum has some athleticism to him, Goff is incredibly light on his feet, and Mannion is a bit plodding in comparison to them.

    I was very relieved to see Cooper out there. Watched him quite a bit with all the other WRs as they did their drills and then as they moved into the scrimmage, and he looked smooth with good hands, just as advertised. I presume the time he missed set him back a bit, and he didn’t really stand out in a busting big plays kind of way or anything. But he is very bold in traffic and across the middle for a small dude, which is also not news to anyone here.

    So right off the top what I saw was a defense that was bringin it. The offense made some plays that were impressive like Goff’s beautiful pass down the middle that was on point, and they won some in the redzone, but looking a bit deeper at things many of the passes would have had some “blown up” receivers. TJ made some hits today that he did not follow through on, where he was in position to lay dudes the F out and he was not the only one. The secondary closed fast and swarmed, and the front seven was in the offensive backfield a lot. I think Fish was real happy with how the defense looked.

    Back to the offense the protections were breaking down a reasonable amount as the DL in particular were going hard. There were quite a few passes that would not have gotten out of the pocket without that red jersey on the QB. I watched GRob struggle a couple times on edge rush (still his greatest weakness) and also do well, and across the OL it was much the same and I thought very good back and forth competition between the units. This is going to sound ridiculous, too, but it seemed like Keenum got more heat than Goff, and have no idea whether it’s the line blocking being better when Goff was in there, the DL being afraid to hurt the #1 draft pick, or whatever. Goff did get swarmed quickly a couple times, like when he dropped to his knees it would have been a very fast sack in a live game so taking the sack and living to throw another day was a good decision by him vice forcing something. The dude who yelled that was probably the same one who yelled some other idiotic things, and our section was crackin jokes about how dudes like him are the reason why we can’t have an effin beer truck. {zn note: M is referring to a tweet where it was reported that Goff was struggling a bit so a member of the crowd yelled “bring in 17!”]

    The receivers overall had a good day I thought. Thomas is just, well, as someone said the other day about him “he belongs.” Really the best way to put it. The dude straight stands out in that he’s very big, and is already playing fast in this system. His feet are really quick, which is something to see with a guy his size. And Quick, man. I gotta admit the dude is looking great, he’s like a different receiver from the one I’ve seen drop everything and run the wrong routes. Marquez goes 100% every single route and is showing good hands and body control, same exact thing with Spruce. Watched coach Groh doing the tennis ball routine with them midpoint and I continue to feel like this is an entirely different group of receivers now, where all of a sudden they all have solid to good hands. It’s weird man. I mean today Britt had a focus drop, but overall he’s movin and catching things and it just seems like an insane turnaround as an entire group so it will be interesting to see if it carries over to preseason games. I am REALLY looking forward to seeing that.

    The TEs are similar to the above as well in that this group straight catches the ball now with good hands as a unit. Higbee is just downright ridiculous. The dude is huge, has a big catch radius, moves like a WR, and just makes whoever throws him the ball look great. Watched him in drills with Thompson throwing the ball I think it was, and he reels the catch in smoothly before having a couple DBs who due to his size get just as good as they gave on the hits. Kendricks looks so much more consistent too, but when you watch these guys live it’s just not even a comparison in terms of imagining who’s gonna add what to this passing game.

    Run game had some good moments but it’s just too hard to tell whether the back would be down if they were playing for real. The D as I mentioned was bringin it, but it did seem like they’re aware they don’t want to be wrapping Gurley up and driving him to the ground like they would in a game. But still, the dude is so damn good he just makes it look easy. Aaron Green in both phases flashed and is really busting his butt to make this roster. Had a really nice run but the pass he caught was more impressive and like all the good catches I saw today had the crowd appreciation going.

    So last but not least the QBs. Here’s where I differ from a lot of what I read tweet-wise. The sack and the moron yelling whatever he yelled don’t matter as I was very pleased overall with Goff’s play. He put up a couple “rookie” throws but also put that ball down the field in the face of the rush with calmness which is far more important and far more telling as to what to expect from him throughout the remainder of camp into preseason. Watching his snaps directly against Keenum’s snaps and it’s not like Goff is suffering by comparison to my eye. Keenum made some nice throws but most of his are short ranged and/or checkdowns, he’s really the same guy I saw get overwhelmed by the whiners late last year. He made one redzone throw on a full run to the right and across his body for a scary TD but it’s one I wouldn’t want to see him attempt again. Goff in the redzone is an assassin. Dude was droppin dimes on the corner route and across the middle for a TD (at least I think that one was from him to Higbee had a lady chatting with us that was a big distraction).

    Tried to download it while I remember it still. Bottom line is this practice only served to boost my excitement about this offense. This team has some significant difference maker type players and we might be witnessing many elements finally coming together on the offensive side of the ball.

    in reply to: 8/5 camp…tweets, vids, articles #50283
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Practice Report 8/5: Rules of the Game

    Myles Simmons

    http://www.therams.com/news-and-events/article-1/Practice-Report-85-Rules-of-the-Game/e270cdca-5b7b-4719-8b23-717f76d1b126

    Every year there are a few changes to the NFL rulebook. Some are designed to enhance player safety, others made to quell any competitive unbalance. On Friday, a crew of NFL officials were at UC Irvine to help explain them to the Rams through a short video presentation and officiating practice.

    “It’s always good when you have a referee and part of his crew out,” head coach Jeff Fisher said. “We’ll kind of informally talk; they’ll informally talk with the players, answer questions and things like that. It’s always a good meeting to attend.”

    “One of the reasons we come to training camp, is to show the video and to answer questions, and then put ourselves on the field with them, so [they can] ask questions out on the field,” said referee John Hussey, who also gave a presentation to the media. “A lot of times they won’t ask a question in the meeting, just for whatever reason. But they’ll come up to you out on the field and they’ll talk in further detail. It’s very helpful for us, and I’ve always found it good to engage with the players in an environment where we can kind of interact and kind of figure stuff out.”

    VIEW GALLERY | 69 Photos
    PHOTOS: #RamsCamp Day 6
    Fisher said he wasn’t too concerned about any of the rule changes, though there was one he brought up that may take some adjusting.

    “There’s not really anything significant other than, to me, from my opinion, other than the touchback,” Fisher said. “We have to wait and see where that goes during the year. Beyond that, subtle changes related to player safety and things like that.”

    While many recent changes to the rulebook have a reputation for benefiting the offense, there are a couple this year at least in part designed for defensive players. The most clear example of that is the elimination of the chop block.

    From the video the officials show to players around the league, a chop block is “a two-man, high-low block, in which a defensive player is engaged above the waist by one offensive player, and blocked at the thigh or below by another offensive player.” As Hussey put it, these blocks have mostly been phased out of offenses. But in the few instances that they do happen, it is a safety issue because of the high risk for lower-leg injuries.

    “If you’re out there and you see it, it’s ugly,” Hussey said. “And it engenders ill will because players have careers. I like [the change].”

    Another point of emphasis this year will be the quarterback feet-first slide. This year, it’s a point of emphasis for signal-callers to get down early if they want full protection from receiving a legal hit by a defender.

    “They were pushing the envelope of getting to the ground,” Hussey said. “And that’s what the point of emphasis is to them, to say, ‘hey, you want max protection and you don’t want to get touched at all, then get down early.’ And that’s the message that we hope is clear.”

    That, however, doesn’t mean a defender has free reign on a quarterback who’s clearly going to the ground — particularly when it’s a player-safety issue.

    If [the quarterback] slides while the defensive contact is imminent, then the defender needs to stay off the head,” Hussey said. “If he’s airborne and he’s launching, and he’s up around the head or neck area [the quarterback is] fouled. Or if [a defender] lowers the crown of his helmet to any part of his body, [the quarterback is] fouled.”

    Another headline-garnering change is two unsportsmanlike conduct penalties resulting in an ejection. Officials have always had the option to eject a player if necessary — for actions such as a punch or spitting. But implementing this rule is akin to making a deterrent so players will be less likely to do whatever they’ve done again.

    “This is really an emphasis toward behavior toward your official and your opponent,” Hussey said. “Taunting, actions towards us — so it’s just putting more depth in the unsportsmanlike [conduct penalties].”

    There are a few more rule changes and points of emphasis that will be implemented for the 2016 season. If you’d like to watch the video the players saw about them, you can view it here.

    EXTRA POINTS

    — The Rams will host Family Day at the Coliseum on Saturday afternoon. The players will strap up their pads at the stadium for the first time since returning to Los Angeles.

    “Oh man, that’s going to be a great feeling. It’s definitely going to be breathtaking,” offensive lineman Rodger Saffold said. “You’re talking about just a ton of people in there. It’s going to be good just to just scrimmage.”

    While the event is free, fans do need to register for tickets. You can do that at the link here.

    Gates open at 1 p.m. and practice will start at 3 p.m.

    — Rookie wide receiver Pharoh Cooper made his return to the practice field on Friday after sitting out a few practices due to a mild quad issue.

    “They’re just being precautionary about it — nothing real, real serious,” Cooper said of his quad. “It felt good to get back on the field today after a couple of days off. It was the first time I could actually put the pads on, so it felt good to be back out there with the boys instead of just watching.”

    — Fisher said cornerback E.J. Gaines has a mild hamstring strain and will be out for a little while.

    “I haven’t ruled him out for Dallas yet, but I’m not anticipating him doing anything tomorrow,” Fisher said.

    — As expected at this point, Fisher confirmed Case Keenum will be the starting quarterback in the Rams’ first preseason game against the Cowboys on Aug. 13. Rookie QB Jared Goff will follow Keenum and get significant playing time.

    “Nothing unusual — what you want to do is you want to play your starting quarterback with your starters and then you start subbing and then Jared comes in,” Fisher said. “He will get to play. I’m sure he will get to play quite a bit — probably play a half.”

    — Finally, the Rams had another special guest at practice as the club hosted new Los Angeles Lakers head coach Luke Walton for Friday’s session. Fisher said he was excited to have Walton around the team.

    “We made contact over a week or so ago and I was really impressed that he wanted to come down and see what we do,” Fisher said. “We got to spend a lot of one-on-one time together today, which was very, very impressive from my standpoint — to have an opportunity to learn his world and he got an opportunity to learn our world.”

    Our Dani Klupenger sat down with Walton for her own one-on-one time with the head coach, which you can view in the video below.

    in reply to: 8/5 camp…tweets, vids, articles #50277
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Case Keenum holding off Jared Goff in Rams quarterback competition

    By RICH HAMMOND / STAFF WRITER

    http://www.ocregister.com/articles/practice-724842-keenum-rams.html

    IRVINE – After the first week of training camp, the Rams’ quarterback battle is, well …

    “Put in number 17,” a fan yelled after Jared Goff kneeled to avoid a “sack” in Friday’s no-contact practice at UC Irvine. Not long after, number 17, Case Keenum, entered and threw a touchdown pass.

    There’s a long way to go before the Rams open their season on Sept. 12 in San Francisco, including four preseason games and a dozens of hours of practice, but at least for one week, Keenum has held off Goff.

    Through the first week of training camp, Keenum has been steadier and made fewer mistakes than Goff, the No. 1 overall pick in this year’s draft. Coach Jeff Fisher said Keenum will start the Rams’ first preseason game, Aug. 13 against Dallas, but that Goff will play as much as a full half in that game.

    “I’m not looking as far forward as that,” Keenum said Friday. “As far as that determining my confidence level, I don’t think it will. I’ve got a job to do, and that’s to lead the offense when I’m out there.”

    Not surprisingly, Goff, a 21-year-old rookie, has been less consistent than Keenum, who is 28 and in his fifth NFL training camp. Goff threw two interceptions in practice Friday but, in the final drill, threw red-zone touchdown passes to Tyler Higbee and Brian Quick.

    Keenum, anointed the starter by Fisher at the end of last season, hasn’t necessarily been dynamic but rarely has made errors. Keenum, undrafted in 2012 and on the Rams’ practice squad as recently as Dec. 2014, said he enjoyed his first-ever week as a training-camp starter.

    “I’m getting a lot more reps,” Keenum said. “My wife came the other day to watch, and usually I’d get three or four passes and she would have 5-10 minutes between reps. She’s like, ‘I can’t even go to the bathroom now. I have to keep watching.’ So it’s fun, and I feel like I’m getting better.”

    It would have been shocking to see Goff, who mostly has taken second-team reps thus far in camp, start next weekend against the Cowboys. That job belongs to Keenum for now, but Fisher said he had yet to determine exactly how many series each quarterback would play.

    “At some point we’ll discuss it next week,” Fisher said. “It’s nothing unusual. You know what you want to do. You play your starting quarterback with your starters and then you start subbing and then Jared comes in. He will get to play, probably quite a bit. He will probably play a half, but we’ll discuss that.”

    WELCOME ‘HOME’

    Players and coaches will get a first look at their home venue for the next three seasons when the Rams hold an open practice at the Coliseum on Saturday at 3:30 p.m.

    The full practice, which the Rams are calling “Family Day,” is free to the public (other than a $20 parking fee) and essentially will be a regular session with some fan-friendly events.

    The practice purpose, though, is to give the team a chance to get acclimated to its new home. Players will get situated in the locker room (usually used by USC) and coaches will navigate the elevators and press box and adjust to any possible technological glitches.

    “It’s a dress rehearsal in every way,” said Bruce Warwick, the Rams’ director of operations.

    NEW RULES

    NFL referee John Hussey attended practice Friday to help instruct players on rule changes for this season. After practice, Hussey planned to show players a 10-minute video and answer questions.

    The rule changes, approved in March, mostly involve player safety. All chop blocks are now illegal, as is taking down an opponent by the back of the jersey in a “horse collar” fashion. Officials also will put a stronger emphasis on some rules, such as hitting below the knee or with the crown of the helmet.

    NOTES

    The Rams announced that J.B. Long will be their radio play-by-play broadcaster, with former UCLA and NFL standout Maurice Jones-Drew as analyst and former Rams defensive lineman D’Marco Farr as sideline analyst. Long most recently worked as a play-by-play announcer for Pac-12 Network. … Cornerback E.J. Gaines missed practice with a hamstring injury, but receiver Pharoh Cooper, who had been out with a quadriceps injury, returned. … Lakers coach Luke Walton watched practice from the field and talked with Fisher when it ended.

    in reply to: 8/5 camp…tweets, vids, articles #50276
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Myles Simmons @MylesASimmons
    Fisher said CB EJ Gaines has a hamstring strain and will be out for a bit. Fisher not ruling him out of the DAL game next week, though.

    in reply to: collected Goff material, early August, during camp #50275
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    I think it’s sensible for Fisher to officially name Keenum the starter and stick with him through at least the first half of the season. The veteran not only gives the Rams the best chance to win right now, but the team believes in his talent and leadership skills. Speaking to several offensive players, I repeatedly heard the word “gamer” and “winner” in reference to the 28-year-old Keenum.

    This gets one thing right IMO but then neglects the chance to notice another.

    Yes, not only is Keenum more in charge, his intangibles are what give him an edge…he self-maximizes.

    But. He comes from the same kind of college offense Goff does. So if Keenum can do it obviously so can Goff.

    in reply to: collected Goff material, early August, during camp #50274
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Jared Goff should begin on bench

    Bucky Brooks

    http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000680715/article/jared-goff-should-begin-on-bench-hue-jacksons-rgiii-project

    Patience is a virtue — in virtually all aspects of life. But it is rarely found in NFL locker rooms.

    In a league where production and performance are paramount, general managers and scouts frequently fall prey to the outside noise and rush players onto the field to justify lofty draft-day selections. This happens with most top picks, but quarterbacks are especially susceptible to microwave treatment when they are selected in the first round — and even more so when they’re taken with a top-10 pick.

    That’s why I’m paying close attention to how the Los Angeles Rams are bringing along Jared Goff.

    The football world will be clamoring to see the No. 1 overall pick when the Rams open their season in front of a national television audience at San Francisco in the final game of Week 1 on Monday, Sept. 12. While I’ve heard all of the rhetoric from coach Jeff Fisher and his staff on resisting the urge to put the rookie out on the field before he is ready, we’ve seen nearly every quarterback selected with a top-five pick over the past five years take the ball as the team’s starter very early in the season. Thus, I traveled to Rams camp fully expecting to see Goff primed and ready to supplant Case Keenum as the team’s starter.

    I mean, on paper, this shouldn’t be a fair fight: Goff boasts prototypical physical dimensions (6-foot-4, 215 pounds), A+ arm talent and a polished game, while Keenum has a smallish stature (6-1, 205 pounds), an average arm and a lack of cachet as a former undrafted free agent and current NFL journeyman. Sure, Keenum led the Rams to a 3-2 record as the team’s part-time starter a season ago, but Fisher wouldn’t seriously consider using the fifth-year pro as a legitimate starter this season. Right?

    To my surprise, Goff isn’t anywhere close to being ready to play as a starting quarterback at this stage of training camp. Now, this isn’t a direct knock on him or his future potential. It can be a process. Having been around some of the best quarterback developers in the game (Mike Holmgren, Andy Reid, Jon Gruden, Steve Mariucci, Dan Henning, Kevin Gilbride, Mike McCarthy and Mike McCoy), I know that young signal callers must check the boxes in three key areas before they are primed to step on the field as a starter:

    » Communication
    » Coverage identification
    » Judgment

    Watching Goff over a full workout, I sensed that — despite widely reported improvement since the end of OTAs and minicamps — the Cal product still has a long way to go before he reaches the standard needed to wrestle the starting job from Keenum.

    After spending his formative years directing a spread offense (Sonny Dykes’ “Bear Raid”), Goff is still mastering the verbiage and communication skills to own the huddle. The lengthy play calls and at-the-line adjustments require far more verbal communication than the no-huddle system he ran in Berkeley. In addition, the constant chatter and identification require complete mastery of the playbook to make split-second decisions at the line. While I’m not privy to the Rams’ playbook or their audible system, I can say that the offense operated with better tempo and pace when Keenum was at the helm. Goff had his moments directing the two-minute offense in team drills, but the pauses between plays were noticeably longer with the rookie in charge.

    Moving on to some of Goff’s post-snap responsibilities, I believe he is still adjusting to the complex coverages routinely employed by NFL coordinators. Rams DC Gregg Williams is one of the most creative tacticians in football, and his carefully crafted pre-snap disguises frequently mask the designated coverage. Thus, opposing quarterbacks must be in tune to the depths of linebackers and safeties in order to get a bead on the blitz or coverage. Keenum efficiently sorted out the myriad disguises and blitzes from the Rams’ starters to find the hot route or open receiver down the field. He was rarely flustered by the constant movement, and his efficiency certainly surprised me, based on the complexity of the defensive looks.

    Meanwhile, despite facing a more static look, Goff struggled a bit against the defense in team drills. Williams frequently aligned his defense in a Cover 2 shell (two deep safeties with corners aligned at 6 to 7 yards) and used a variety of simple zone (Cover 2, Cover 3) or zone-blitz (five-man rush with three deep and three under) concepts against the rookie. These defenses are the equivalent of what you would see in an NFL 101 class, yet Goff routinely had a tough time finding the open guy. And when he did identify the open man, he was frequently late with his throw, resulting in a contested catch or off-target toss down the field. At the NFL level, quarterbacks must throw with timing and anticipation to consistently complete passes in tight windows between multiple defenders.

    Now, I don’t want to be too critical of a young passer in the opening stretch of his first NFL training camp, but judgment is arguably the most important part of playing the position, and Goff seems so overwhelmed by the speed of the game that he’s been inconsistent with his decisions. Some of his poor determinations are understandable, due to the uncertainty that plagues every young QB, but he also has been prone to making some “hero” throws in traffic. In the workout I attended, Goff threw four passes that should’ve been intercepted, each the result of a forced throw at intermediate range despite the fact that a checkdown was available underneath.

    To be fair, most quarterbacks are reluctant to take the open checkdown when they believe they can make a “hero” throw. But Goff is in line for a number of turnovers off tips and overthrows until he develops the patience and poise to settle for a short completion instead of gambling on a “wow” play. He might foster these characteristics after a few preseason games, but I believe it will take him some time to learn the management skills needed to start for a competitive team.

    Taking all of this into account, I think it’s sensible for Fisher to officially name Keenum the starter and stick with him through at least the first half of the season. The veteran not only gives the Rams the best chance to win right now, but the team believes in his talent and leadership skills. Speaking to several offensive players, I repeatedly heard the word “gamer” and “winner” in reference to the 28-year-old Keenum. In fact, one Rams receiver said the offense would thrive in 2016 with Keenum at the helm, even though everyone expects Goff to eventually become a “baller” at the position.

    To get a management perspective, I talked to several team officials who suggested Keenum can succeed because he has a clear understanding of his limitations and won’t try to do too much with the ball in his hands. Unlike some quarterbacks who shrug off the “game manager” label, Keenum seemingly has embraced the approach — and everyone in the building believes he won’t mess it up if he gets the chance. Given that Los Angeles has a budding superstar in Todd Gurley who can pound the football, savvy game management from the quarterback position could work quite well for this team.

    For the past several months, I thought the prospect of Keenum taking the field with the starting unit was simply the product of coachspeak. But after spending time at Rams camp, I believe the team should play the veteran quarterback until the youngster proves that he is ready to handle the job. This is the blueprint Fisher successfully used with a young Steve McNair during his time heading the Oilers/Titans. Despite entering the NFL as the third overall pick in the 1995 NFL Draft, McNair didn’t become a full-time starter until 1997. He went on to make three Pro Bowls and earn NFL MVP honors in 2003. Fisher should keep this in mind, to help Goff eventually reach his full potential as the Rams’ franchise quarterback.

    in reply to: 8/5 camp…tweets, vids, articles #50273
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Ryan Kartje ✔ @Ryan_Kartje
    Undrafted RB Aaron Green is having himself a day at #Rams practice. Busted a long, shifty run, then caught a deep pass on the sideline

    Vincent Bonsignore @DailyNewsVinny
    Not sure how the numbers game breaks for him in L.A. but #Rams rookie RB Aaron Green has an #NFL future

    Ryan Kartje @Ryan_Kartje
    Tyler Higbee running with the 1’s again for team portion along with Lance Kendricks, who is also out there in 2-TE base set

    Myles Simmons @MylesASimmons
    Mike Thomas gets a snap/reception with the first-team offense in 11-on-11. Believe that’s the first time we’ve seen him with that unit.

    Austin Green @AustinGreenLA
    Just got the full Jared Goff experience at #RamsCamp. A lazer completed through coverage followed up by a really bad interception.

    Rich Hammond@Rich_Hammond
    EJ Gaines hasn’t practiced for Rams today. Fisher had said Gaines left Wednesday’s practice early.

    Myles Simmons ✔ @MylesASimmons
    Two TD passes from Goff to end a red zone 11-on-11 period — one to Higbee and the second to Quick.

    Vincent Bonsignore @DailyNewsVinny
    #Rams rookie TE Tyler Higbee being a beast in a spirited 11-on-11 Red Zone drill with 2 TD catches

    Ryan Kartje @Ryan_Kartje
    Rookie TE Tyler Higbee continues to impress. Two nice touchdowns in red zone offense work. His size could be a serious weapon.

    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    in reply to: camp reports for 8/2 #50270
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Hacksaw_64

    Better late than never. (posted 8/5)

    Rolled in early. As expected, it was a lighter crowd than the weekend. Hard Knocks was there in full force.

    I started the day by watching the OL warm up right in front of me. Garrett Reynolds was the first OL on the scene and he ran right up to me and said hello. I didn’t realize how massive he really was watching him play last season on TV. He stands out as one of our largest models on the OL. He may be the tallest of the bunch. Coupled with his huge frame and surprising agility, he looks to me like a prototype OT.

    Cody Whichmann, in contrast to Reynolds doesn’t quite look the part up close. He’s much smaller than I envisioned. On top of that with his helmet off he looks like he is just out of HS. I got a little bit nervous thinking that this is the kid that’s blocking for our Pro Bowl RB and rookie #1 pick QB. Clearly looks can be deceiving, but still I thought it was funny.

    Saffold ran out and promptly started working on agility drills. Not sure about his shoulder but his legs look just fine.

    Battle was out there early getting his work in. He is massive too. Really looks like he worked on conditioning in the off-season. He’s one of my camp wildcards. If he continues to develop, it going to be huge for the Rams.

    GRob was the last guy to show up. Not what I wanted to see….

    Havs was there but not in pads.

    Practice really opened with the entire team doing stretches as a unit as opposed to groups as they did in the prior practices. The Rams were getting serious today. It was the first legit practice of camp IMO. Training wheels were off.

    Mike Groh was calling every play in the huddle for the entire day. It looked to me like he was running the show. Boras was back on the sideline watching intently, Fisher also kept sticking his nose in the huddle.

    Keenum looked like Keenum. Made a couple nice throws. A lot of check downs. And some real head scratching inaccurate throws.

    Goff had a nice day. He does a lot of little things right. He repeatedly threw a perfect back shoulder pass right on the money in goaline reps. He threw a nice corner fade ball and completed a post to the back of the endzone with authority.

    For most of the day Goff looked much better pre-snap. He seemed to get the ball to his best matchup most of the time.

    He made a couple “wow” throws again today. He hit Mike Thomas perfectly in stride on a slant over the middle for about a 20 yard gain. He hit Nelson Spruced own the seam with an absolute perfect pass for about a 35 yard gain. He probably scores on that play.

    He had his troubles handling the snap from Eric Kush, who is now our backup center. (yes be scared)

    He missed Higbee in the endzone with a ball that he overthrew high and out of the back of the endzone. If your gonna miss in the redzone, that’s how you do it.

    One thing I noticed is Goff was really staring down his receivers too much sometimes and not getting to his full progression of reads. I’m sure that will come in time.

    He showed off for the second time his “jump pass”. Didn’t know he had that in his arsenal. He completed a bullet jump pass on kind of a broken play to his blanketed receiver sitting down in the middle underneath and in heavy traffic.

    Mannion looked much better. Had a series of on target passes. He looked actually pretty crisp running the offense. Much better arm than Keenum. Had a real nice throw to McRoberts who made a great catch and stayed in bounds. McRoberts is no slouch!

    Kenny Britt made an appearance today. He looks a little on the out of shape heavy side to me. He’s another one of those guys that it doesn’t quite look like he goes all out all the time in practice. He made one nice catch where he seemed to decide to turn on the jets.

    Higbee is a beast and is probably going to start sooner than later.

    Hemmingway didn’t get reps with the offense.

    Kendricks had a bad drop that hit him right in the hands.

    Mike Thomas is for real. He made a real nice site adjustment on a ball in the air to haul it in for a TD.

    Duke Williams continues to impress. Made a great one handed grab on a bad ball. Made another great catch in the back of the endzone, didn’t get his feet inbounds.

    Quick dropped a couple very catchable balls in drills. Looked like he was getting moved down the depth chart. He was getting some reps with the second team in the second half of practice. He redeemed himself by making a nice catch in the back of the endzone that he had to go up to get. He actually held on. The entire team and crowd cheered in amazement.

    Tavon is our best receiver. Had 3 nice catches. 2 for TD’s 1 he was wide open and beat his defender badly.

    Gurley opened up with a pitch to the left for a legit 20 yard gain around GRob. He looks a notch faster this year.

    Benny showed of his jets. He looks lighter and faster as well. Maybe its the number change.. #23 .

    As far as OL goes.

    Overall they handled the DL much better than previous practices.

    Kush is horrible. We are in big trouble if Barnes gets hurt. = Rams achilles heal.

    Take this with a grain of salt because I wasn’t focusing on them all that much but..

    Saffold and Jamon Brown both were having problems. In fact our interior line didn’t look good vs power or speed. Ethan Westbrooks, Donald and Brockers were eating them alive still way too much.

    Battle and Robinson held there own. Robinson got beat by Quinn a couple times but that’s to be expected. Overall he held up OK.

    Darrell Williams seemed to hang in pretty well backing up at LT. He may be another surprise.

    Pharoah Cooper wasn’t in pads but sure looked like he wanted to be. He was shadowing WR’s in drills. Also, he was working with Tavon on Punt Returns. Tavon was coaching him up.

    Stedman Bailey was at the practice throwing the ball around.

    At corner…

    Trujo and Sensabaugh got first team reps on the outside. There was also a combination where it was Trujo and Joyner as the two outside corners. Gaines is on the second team as of now.

    Roberson actually looked pretty good

    They seem to be taking a good look at Troy Hill, he got a ton of reps…

    Mo Alexander and McDonald again were starting safties. Both struggled in coverage.

    Christian Bryant looked horrible

    Bryce Hagar looks tiny.

    Ogletree got beat badly trying to cover a back out the backfield.

    Coples had one real nice disruptive play.

    Overall a much cleaner practice on the Offensive side. You can tell the coaches are really focusing on the offense. They have yet to open up the passing game. But clearly that is the focal point. One step at a time.

    That’s all for now.

    I’ll be heading back early next week.

    in reply to: 8/3-8/5 … Camp reports #50259
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Ramzee

    SOME FOLLOW-UP

    Tavon super pumped after catching a big gain on a deep out to the sideline. You can see him flexing. Coverage by (#24) Christian Bryant, who nearly tipped it.


    As I keep saying Tavon is electric with the ball in his hands. They will find ways to put the ball in his hands. As you can see from the pics above, they have him running down field routes now too. Not just bubble screens and reverses.

    Quick has been getting a lot of end zone TD’s on jump balls and fades. Tru doesn’t seem to be going too hard out there right now in some drills so I’m sure things aren’t exactly as they would appear in a real game. In practice though Quick has been effective in the red zone.

    The TE’s are getting a ton of targets in camp. Harkey looks like a receiving tight end out there. Cunningham is getting a lot of touches as well. Higbee stood out a bit on Tuesday and wasn’t thrown at much on Wednesday. He did go in motion though a bunch on Wednesday.

    Britt has made a few highlight reel diving catches and has been effective on the sideline routes.

    The depth has been getting the majority of the snaps at the WR position. Out of the bunch so far I like Michael Thomas and Duke Williams. Don’t sleep on Nelson either. He’s made a bunch of catches in camp when his reps come up. Williams seems a little raw but he’s big and has been effective in a lot of his reps. Thomas seems to be a nice hands catcher and do something with the ball in his hands.

    in reply to: harsh eye on both candidates #50247
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Besides, I;m cranky.

    in reply to: Farr will be Rams in-game sideline reporter #50241
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Translation: He wants to cover the Rams in LA rather than the FastLane. I don’t believe anything else. I hope it works out well for him. He is good in the broadcast booth.

    The Fast Lane doesn;t cover the Rams.

    And, whether he wanted to do it in LA is not relevant really because LA people either wanted to hire him or they didn’t.

    Besides, it’s no surprise that an analyst covering a team would like to be in the same town as the team.

    I agree with your take on Farr as an analyst. I like him.

    in reply to: Movies are really really bad this summer #50236
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Any word on the new Bourne movie?

    Yeah…with some exceptions, it’s sort of disliked.

    http://www.metacritic.com/movie/jason-bourne

    in reply to: harsh eye on both candidates #50224
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Um, no. I’m not ‘esteeming’ Obama for displaying ‘grace’ and ‘dignity’.
    He’s living about the most privileged life a human being can live.

    Have to disagree with that. There’s missing things in how you put that.

    For one, so is Trump (living a privileged life). Notice they do it differently.

    And besides that’s not what the guy said anyway. What he said was among them his cool-headed grace under enormous pressure and the profound dignity with which he’s endured racism and pointed us beyond it.

    As soon as any of us have endured racism maybe we can judge.

    There’s one thing when class gets ignored in analysis. It’s another when we can’t give someone credit just because they’ve acquired wealth.

    —————-
    Nah, i disagree. What “enormous pressure” is a wealthy President of the USA, under? Enormous pressure is when you aren’t sure you can pay the rent and your kids might get evicted. That is ‘enormous pressure’.

    You can ‘esteem’ him all you want – I’ll not. 🙂

    w
    v

    In terms of paying or not paying the rent, just different kinds of pressure. One doesn’t negate the other. I am sure if you said to the writer, look poor people struggling to hold on are under pressure too, he would agree. And probably point out that it’s not either/or. Acknowledging one thing doesn’t negate the other thing. In terms of the president, what the writer refers to, of course, is the enormous pressure in being a president–that’s just making decisions in a glass house, with intense scrutiny, and often with enormous consequences. Taken in the abstract, that’s just true. I don’t think wealth negates that.

    I wasn’t talking about esteem for Obama, and whether I have it or you don’t. That wasn’t even on my mind. I was talking about sentences and their logic. It went toward what class analysis means. To me, if class analysis is to be effective and sound, two things have to happen. First, it cannot be separated, especially in the USA, from gender and race. The way I understand things, that’s all a big ball of tied together strings. To me it’s equally a flaw when any single one of those things gets ignored. Second, I can’t simply dismiss someone only because they do have wealth. To me, that’s not class analysis, it’s something else.

    In terms of Obama himself, I have very mixed feelings, and have since he was first a candidate years ago. My feelings haven’t changed. In terms of my own political ideas and wishes and analysis, he comes up far short. But at the same time I more or less knew that (as you did) when he was first running in the primaries, way back when.

    in reply to: harsh eye on both candidates #50222
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    You’re trying to “debate it.” To me, that won’t work. It’s Rocky and Bullwinkle – that trick never works. All I personally see in this case like many others is you taking your own opinions as true, and therefore trying to convey that truth persuasively.

    Problem is I have been in this particular debate, and variations thereof, for probably 45 years. And, so, being a well-meaning but also cranky old bastard, I just shrug at the debate, say let’s be a coalition, and move on. Way I see it most REAL political investments are at an emotional level too deep to be reasoned with. So, when it comes to alliances and coalitions, I like my approach better. We differ, we know we have impasses, we acknowledge that and move forward.

    Now how can we be useful (in the best sense) to one another.

    Well, one way we can be useful is to give each other the benefit of the doubt. Some of the terms you use seem unnecessary to me, and get in the way of that. Like “routine” and “trick” and, again, the original “purity” accusation.

    Why use them at all? To me, they cause the “impasse” by changing the subject from the political issues on hand to one where we argue about the accuracy of meta-terms — with those meta-terms being implemented largely as a comment on one’s methods and (perhaps) hidden motivations, rather than the political issues themselves. Indirectly, cutting very close to directly, this makes the discussion about the poster, instead of the subject of national politics.

    I’d much prefer talking about the latter.

    As in, Can’t we all just get along?

    ;>)

    Just letting you know how I see all such inter-left debates of this kind.

    I can not say it but then I will still feel it.

    The best bet for you is just don’t take it so personally. I am just saying where I am coming from. The whole thing is about perspective.

    And on top of it I always believe that many presumed rational arguments are in fact entirely rhetorical. That won’t change either.

    So don’t take this stuff personally since the entire point is just to spell out a perspective. I just gave you a perspective, it;s how I see it.

    And so to me this is not useful if it is a discussion about “us” or about my rhetoric or your rhetoric.

    The useful stuff is beyond all that, IMO. Like I said before. Now we move on. Everyone accepts everyone else for what they are and just discusses stuff. Fair enough?

    in reply to: harsh eye on both candidates #50218
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Hypothetical analogy:

    I’m a part of an environmental action group that seeks to protect one million acres of wilderness, and seeks an end to all development on public lands, period.

    Candidate X in the Dem party suggests we save 100,000 acres, but says nothing about stopping current development on existing public lands. Candidate Y suggests 25,000, also without any word on current public land use. The GOP is unanimous in their desire to open up existing protected wilderness even more to developers, and no GOP candidate is suggesting adding new wilderness protections.

    Our group, while saying Candidate X doesn’t go far enough, and why (white papers, press conferences, etc), says Candidate X is preferable to Candidate Y on this matter. The supporters of Candidate Y then launch concerted attacks against our group which include mockery for our supposed “starry-eyed, naive, impractical vision,” and our overzealous attachment to “purity tests.” etc. etc. Candidate Y’s surrogates constantly scold us by saying “Don’t let the perfect be the enemy of the good.”

    We don’t, in fact, see the the protection of just 25,000 acres, with no attempt to prevent further exploitation of existing public lands, as anything approaching “the good,” and we admit that our own positions are far from “the perfect,” because they don’t go far enough, protect enough lands or species, and are not integrated enough with an international commitment to the same. We admit that our own requests are driven in part by what we see as “politically possible,” with the right coalition, media, rhetoric, demonstrations, etc. etc.

    You’re trying to “debate it.” To me, that won’t work. It’s Rocky and Bullwinkle–that trick never works. All I personally see in this case like many others is you taking your own opinions as true, and therefore trying to convey that truth persuasively.

    Problem is I have been in this particular debate, and variations thereof, for probably 45 years. And, so, being a well-meaning but also cranky old bastard, I just shrug at the debate, say let’s be a coalition, and move on. Way I see it most REAL political investments are at an emotional level too deep to be reasoned with. So, when it comes to alliances and coalitions, I like my approach better. We differ, we know we have impasses, we acknowledge that and move forward.

    Now how can we be useful (in the best sense) to one another.

    in reply to: harsh eye on both candidates #50214
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    IMO, whenever someone complains about others seeking “purity” or “ideological purity” or says “Don’t let the perfect be the enemy of the good,” they are actually helping to freeze the possible where it currently is, or worse.

    In short, not only is it inaccurate, it’s not at all helpful.

    Well just as you don’t buy my routine I don’t buy yours (ie. what I quoted). Yours is no more helpful. I reject it as categorically as you reject anything I said.

    So now we know our potential impasses. Which is worth knowing. And. No point in arguing about it.

    Now we move on. Everyone accepts everyone else for what they are and just discusses stuff. Fair enough?

    in reply to: harsh eye on both candidates #50212
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    This has got to be the crappiest election, evah.

    When was the last time there was a genuine grassroots left (albeit new deal left) candidacy that went as far as Sanders?

    If in fact there was a last time.

    I get the wanting to win now thing but one thing people will always contend with when it comes to me in a political debate…not only am I NOT a purist, I can’t stand purism.

    You push, if it falls short, you do the pragmatic thing and then immediately start pushing again.

    I have spent my whole life dealing with dogmatic purists on the left. I consider them hopeless pains in the ass.

    As a leftist, my favorite satirical portraits of the left are from Monty Python and The Life of Brian.

    in reply to: harsh eye on both candidates #50206
    Avatar photozn
    Moderator

    Um, no. I’m not ‘esteeming’ Obama for displaying ‘grace’ and ‘dignity’.
    He’s living about the most privileged life a human being can live.

    Have to disagree with that. There’s missing things in how you put that.

    For one, so is Trump (living a privileged life). Notice they do it differently.

    And besides that’s not what the guy said anyway. What he said was among them his cool-headed grace under enormous pressure and the profound dignity with which he’s endured racism and pointed us beyond it.

    As soon as any of us have endured racism maybe we can judge.

    There’s one thing when class gets ignored in analysis. It’s another when we can’t give someone credit just because they’ve acquired wealth.

Viewing 30 posts - 37,831 through 37,860 (of 47,064 total)