Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
znModeratorLMU93
I think ideally they would get Talib back for week 5 and Peters is out for 3 games. Ideally. This is why they signed Shields. Hopefully Troy Hill shows up like 2017 Troy Hill and not the 2018 preseason version.
znModeratorJared Goff quietly leads Rams to perfect 3-0 start
Michael Silver
LOS ANGELES — The black Range Rover pulled toward the road connecting the northwest corner of the Coliseum to the City of Angels, creeping up alongside what was left of the friends and family section at the end of the locker-room tunnel. The man in the passenger seat was clearly in a hurry Sunday evening, what with a short week officially having begun, but suddenly the car came to a stop, and the tinted window on the driver’s side slid down to reveal the face of the NFL’s hottest young coach.
“Your son balled today,” Sean McVay said, gesturing toward a smiling man standing alongside an adjacent fence. And as Jerry Goff accepted the coach’s praise of his son, Jared, the Los Angeles Rams’ third-year quarterback, the proud papa felt compelled to pay his respects to the play-calling prodigy who is the NFL’s reigning coach of the year.
“He’s lucky to have you,” Goff told McVay.
“I feel that way about him,” McVay replied.
A few seconds later, McVay’s girlfriend, Veronika Khomyn, pulled the Range Rover out of the lot, leaving behind a 35-23 victory over the Los Angeles Chargers that pushed the Rams to 3-0 and decided the Fight For L.A. by unanimous decision.
If you’re inclined to assume this was nothing more than simple pleasantries being exchanged in the ebullient wake of the team’s best start in 17 seasons, you’re missing the message behind McVay’s glowing assessment of his quarterback: Goff is not the product of his system. He is the pulse of it.
“Saying he’s a system player — that’s just disrespectful,” McVay told me after the game, still steamed over a question suggesting as much that he’d received in a press conference last Wednesday. “It’s a total discredit to a great player. Those who know, know. Flip the tape on. People who know what it looks like to play the quarterback position at a high level know what they’re seeing.”
“I know this: I wouldn’t want to be working with anybody else other than Jared Goff right now.”
Flip on the tape. Go ahead. Start with the third-and-8 shotgun snap from his own 47-yard line that Goff received with 12:51 left in the third quarter and the Rams up 21-13. McVay had called a play anticipating zone coverage, but the Chargers went with a man-to-man alignment, and the designated man-beater target (receiver Robert Woods) wasn’t able to run the route of his choosing.
As second-year wideout Cooper Kupp patiently explained to me later, “Robert had bad leverage on the route. He wanted to go inside, but (the defender) was inside. I was maybe the third or fourth read, but it all broke down, and I just tried to keep it alive.”
With pressure closing in, Goff slid forward in the pocket, and slightly to his right. Defensive end Issac Rochell was coming from Goff’s left; defensive end Melvin Ingram swooped in from the right. And closing in quickly from behind Goff, blitzing linebacker Uchenna Nwosu dove into the back of his legs.
“I had gone through all my reads, four or five of them, and I was completely off schedule,” Goff said later. “Then Cooper flashed — that was just him being a football player — and I was able to get it there.”
Said Kupp: “It was 100-percent off schedule. Like, double off-schedule. But he got me the ball, and that definitely doesn’t happen if Jared’s not willing to hang in there as long as he did.”
What happened was that Goff zipped a glorious dart toward the right sideline that Kupp caught in-stride at the Chargers’ 30. Cornerback Trevor Williams, who trailed Kupp by a step, grabbed the receiver from behind, but Kupp kept right on churning forward, and by the 20 he had shed Williams completely, continuing on his way to a 53-yard touchdown pass.
It was one of many, many impressive throws by Goff on a day when he, and the Rams’ offense, put up some strikingly prodigious numbers.
Goff completed 29-of-36 passes for 354 yards and three touchdowns, with another scoring throw overturned by a replay review that ruled receiver Brandin Cooks had been stopped at the 1-yard line. He did get dinged for an end-zone interception, with Chargers rookie safety Derwin James making a nice read on a corner throw intended for tight end Gerald Everett.
No worries: The Rams’ Cory Littleton responded by blocking a Drew Kaser punt in the end zone, with teammate Blake Countess recovering for a touchdown. And Goff, after a Chargers touchdown drive, responded by completing his next six passes to set up Sam Ficken’s 46-yard field goal on the final play of the first half.
“This guy’s a total stud,” McVay said of Goff after exiting the locker room long after the game. “I think people don’t realize how calm he is. On the touchdown to Cooper he has four guys on him, two guys practically hanging on him, and he makes a play. He’s fearless, man. It’s hard enough to make plays in rhythm, and when things look the way you want them to look. But when things break down and he can still keep plays alive and make big-time throws… well, that’s a whole different level of good.”
It’s early — and the Rams have the sure-to-be-peeved-in-the-wake-of-a-brutal-home-loss-to-Buffalo Minnesota Vikings coming to town for a stiff Thursday Night Football test — but McVay’s offense, the league’s best in 2017, appears to be even better this year.
On Sunday, Goff and friends put up 521 yards of offense, the most by a Rams team since an overtime game in 2006 — and the most in four quarters of football since 2000, the heart of the Greatest Show On Turf era. Additionally, L.A. had 33 first downs, the most by any NFL team since the Saints midway through the 2015 season.
Goff became the third quarterback in league history to complete consecutive games with at least 350 passing yards and a completion percentage of 75 or above. And the Rams, not coincidentally, are 3-0 for the first time since 2001.
So yeah, the system is tremendous. Goff, however, is far more than a nondescript administrator.
“That dude’s a freaking monster,” said Russell Okung, the Chargers’ veteran left tackle. “And I think what makes him a monster is he’s incredibly consistent. Consistent players do the best in this league. You know what to expect every time. He takes the easy throws when they’re there, and then when he does go over the top, those (receivers) make plays.
“In this league, that’s a winning formula. Don’t give me the flashy guy; give me the guy who you can depend on every time.”
Right now, the metaphorical flashbulbs seem to be focused on a slew of other prolific and promising young quarterbacks, from Patrick Mahomes, to Carson Wentz, to Deshaun Watson — and to Baker Mayfield, Sam Darnold and the other members of the current rookie class.
Goff, for whatever reason, seems to get lost in the wash, even as he cleans up in Tinseltown.
“People don’t talk about him,” said Andrew Whitworth, the Rams’ All-Pro left tackle. “From the start, people were saying he was overdrafted, and now I think they’re sitting there waiting for the opportunity to say that maybe they were right. Yet he’s done nothing but continue to prove them wrong, and he’s getting better and better.
“You feel the command, and his poise is what blows you away. Week after week; good play, bad play; he comes back, explains to us what happened and tells us what we need to do next. He can literally communicate so calmly in the moment, and it’s mind-blowing how relaxed he is on the football field.”
Not surprisingly, Goff had a relaxed response to the notion that he’s getting less hype than some of his contemporaries.
“No idea,” he replied. “Look — with a great running back (Todd Gurley, who ran for 105 yards and a touchdown Sunday) and a really good defense, that can happen. I don’t know if they’re talking about me. I also don’t care. If we’re 3-0, it’s all good.”
Moments after McVay’s Range Rover pulled away from the Coliseum on Sunday evening, Goff’s mother, Nancy, took her son’s indifference a step further.
“We love it,” she said of the relative lack of attention her son’s exploits are generating. “That’s the best– because then you can sneak through the back door. The worst is when they do the whole ‘Mr. Perfect’ thing, like (when Goff was a Cal junior) before (the Golden Bears played) Utah — and then, five interceptions. Right now it’s quiet, and we’re winning, and it couldn’t be better. This is exactly where he wants to be.”
Soon Jared emerged from the locker room, and he and his parents headed out in the L.A. twilight. Nobody followed. Rest assured, they like it that way
znModerator==
I can't stop watching this. https://t.co/8F4sOEZ3y3
— Ross Tucker (@RossTuckerNFL) September 24, 2018
==
Browns (1-1-1) have a better record than the…
Patriots
Cowboys
Seahawks
Steelers
49ers
Cardinals
Lions
Giants
Raiders
Chargers
Texans
Colts
Jets
Bills
Falcons— Andrew Siciliano (@AndrewSiciliano) September 24, 2018
==
Eerie. A few hours *before* Patrick Mahomes' ridiculous touchdown scramble-throw today, his high school coach sent me this. Look at the flick of the wrist. He's 16. pic.twitter.com/04EvNFQTda
— Robert Klemko (@RobertKlemko) September 24, 2018
==
.@buffalobills went to @vikings and took them behind the wood shed, took their lunch money and physically whipped. No exotic schemes, no fancy gameplans. This should send a MEMO around the league. This is how to play the game. ❤️🏈❤️🏈. #BaldyBreakdowns pic.twitter.com/okTeETNRRD
— Brian Baldinger (@BaldyNFL) September 24, 2018
September 24, 2018 at 2:05 am in reply to: reporters on the Chargers game (articles, tweets, vids) #91289
znModerator#Rams move to 3-0, but pay a steep price with injuries. Jared Goff debunks system QB talk, as if that was ever really a thing. Robert Woods takes his turn to shine. All that and more from a great football day in L.A. My story in @TheAthletic 👇👇 https://t.co/iB5spQZVeV
— Vincent Bonsignore (@VinnyBonsignore) September 24, 2018
znModeratorSam Farmer@LATimesfarmer
With every one of these games, it becomes increasingly evident what Les Snead and the rest of the Rams contingent saw in Jared Goff.September 24, 2018 at 1:00 am in reply to: reporters on the Chargers game (articles, tweets, vids) #91283
znModeratorGoff, Offense Fires on All Cylinders to Beat the Bolts
https://www.therams.com/news/goff-offense-fires-on-all-cylinders-to-beat-the-bolts
September 24, 2018 at 12:08 am in reply to: reporters on the Chargers game (articles, tweets, vids) #91280
znModeratorRefocused, NFL Week 3: Los Angeles Rams 35, Los Angeles Chargers 23
RAMS
Quarterback Jared Goff found success throwing the ball down the field Sunday. On 11 attempts, Goff completed 9 for 187 yards, a touchdown, and an interception.
The Rams offensive line continued to dominate. They opened up gaping holes all game long in the run game and only allowed pressure on four of Jared Goff’s 38 dropbacks.
Aaron Donald and Ndamukong Suh continue to be a handful. They may have combined for only one sack, but both were in Philip Rivers’ lap all day. Both interior defensive linemen registered at least five quarterback pressures.
Sam Shields looked solid filling in for the injured Marcus Peters. His pass breakup in the end zone in the fourth quarter was an incredibly intelligent play, as he peeled off his coverage to help safety Lamarcus Joyner.
CHARGERS
Second-year wide receiver Mike Williams looked every bit worthy of the first round pick the Chargers used on him. Williams looked physically imposing on both of his touchdowns, and he hauled in four of his six targets for 81 receiving yards.
As soon as the Chargers got into obvious passing situations, they were toast with the holes on their offensive line. Left guard Dan Feeney and right tackle Sam Tevi both gave up five-plus pressures on the day, and quarterback Philip Rivers was given little to no time to orchestrate the offense effectively.
The Chargers desperately miss Joey Bosa‘s pass-rushing ability up front. No player in the Chargers front seven recorded multiple pressures, and they struggled to get in Jared Goff‘s face.
Derwin James continues to be the bright spot in the Chargers secondary. He showed cornerback like skills by breaking on an out route in the end zone and by picking off the pass in the first half.
Keys to the game
Los Angeles Rams: The Rams offensive line put on another stellar performance and gave Jared Goff and the high-powered Rams offense the required time to effectively move the ball.
Los Angeles Chargers: The Chargers’ offensive line struggled every bit as much as the Rams’ line succeeded. With little to no time in the pocket, Rivers struggled to get the ball into the hands of his playmakers.
znModeratorA small thing but fwiw…right now there are just 3 3-0 teams. Rams, Miami, and Chiefs.
Tampa hasn’t played yet so by tomorrow night it could be 4.
September 23, 2018 at 9:55 pm in reply to: reporters on the Chargers game (articles, tweets, vids) #91271
znModeratorSeven Stats: Rams Best Chargers 35-23 in First L.A. Meeting
https://www.therams.com/news/seven-stats-rams-best-chargers-35-23-in-first-l-a-meeting
Near-career day for Jared Goff and another high-flying, 30-point game
Rams Outlast Chargers With 35-23 Win, Improve to 3-0
https://www.therams.com/news/rams-outlast-chargers-with-35-23-win-improve-to-3-0
Rams Overcome Injuries, but Depth Will be Tested vs. Minnesotahttps://www.therams.com/news/rams-overcome-injuries-but-depth-will-be-tested-vs-minnesota
znModeratorEasley went out of the game too.
…
I thought I saw Easley back in the game towards the end?
Could be.
znModeratorEasley went out of the game too.
…
September 23, 2018 at 8:52 pm in reply to: Niners fear Garoppolo suffered serious knee injury… #91265
znModeratorJimmy Garoppolo likely tore ACL in 49ers’ 38-27 at Kansas City
Eric Branch
https://www.sfchronicle.com/49ers/article/Jimmy-Garoppolo-sustains-knee-injury-in-49ers-13251683.php
KANSAS CITY, Mo. — The 49ers have endured more humiliating losses in Kansas City than the one they endured Sunday, but none more devastating.
In a September defeat that felt, in some ways, like the end of their season, they fear they lost franchise quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo for the season with a torn ACL in a 38-27 loss to the Chiefs at Arrowhead Stadium.
Garoppolo was injured late in the fourth quarter when his left knee buckled before he absorbed a huge hit from cornerback Steven Nelson along the left sideline at the end of a 13-yard run. Garoppolo immediately grabbed for his left knee and was carted to the locker room after spending several minutes in the medical tent on the sideline.
After the game, teammates wandered from the locker room into an adjacent training room to check on Garoppolo. At one point, he sat shirtless on a table with several members of the medical staff around him. He later exited the training room on crutches and asked members of the team staff where he could find his family members who had attended the game.
Inside linebacker Reuben Foster was among the players who checked on Garoppolo, and he immediately knew his injury was serious based on his expression.
“I just see in his face, and he was just like,” Foster said, shaking his head. “I was like, ‘Hey, brother, we’ve got you. … We’re going to fight for you no matter what.’ He was down. With an injury like that, you have no choice but to be down.”
Before Garoppolo’s injury, the 49ers already had dealt with another nightmare at Arrowhead. After losing their previous three games in Kansas City by a combined score of 116-19, they trailed 35-10 at halftime. In the first half, the Chiefs’ five possessions featured touchdown drives of 57, 84, 75, 72 and 68 yards.
Still, if not for Garoppolo’s injury, the loss wouldn’t have beencrushing: The 49ers entered as underdogs to an unbeaten team and are now 1-2 with 13 games left to play.
The postgame scene made it clear more than a game had been lost.
Wide receiver Marquise Goodwin exited the locker room and quietly embraced CEO Jed York’s twin sisters, Jenna and Mara, who looked emotional.
Goodwin said the loss of Garoppolo was a “downer,” tight end George Kittle said it “sucks,” left tackle Joe Staley termed it a “bummer.”
Foster, who said it was “heartbreaking,” succinctly summed up what it meant to lose the quarterback who last year led a 1-10 team to a 5-0 finish. “We had big hopes for Jimmy,” Foster said. “He made us who we are.”
In the aftermath, head coach Kyle Shanahan and various players uttered variations on the NFL maxim of “next man up.”
CB Ahkello Witherspoon: After a rugged performance in Week 2, he was benched and replaced by Jimmie Ward, before entering when Richard Sherman was hurt. In the second half, he committed two more penalties (holding, pass interference), bringing his total to four in the past two games.
RB Matt Breida: After entering as the NFL’s rushing leader, he survived a first-half injury scare and had 90 yards on 10 carries.
And for the 49ers, it will be C.J. Beathard. Last year, as a rookie, Beathard started five games after Brian Hoyer was benched. Beathard had a 1-4 record and 69.2 passer rating while earning high marks for his grit and toughness.
On Sunday, on the first play after Garoppolo was injured, Beathard tossed an apparent 7-yard touchdown to Kittle on 4th-and-goal, but the score was negated by a pass-interference penalty.
The 49ers settled for a field goal to trim the deficit to 38-27 with 5:12 left, but the Chiefs responded with three first downs to run out the clock.
Minutes later, Shanahan opened his news conference with the biggest news.
“With Jimmy, it’s a knee,” he said. “We fear an ACL.”
Later, Shanahan was asked about looking ahead to the rest of the season without Garoppolo, who signed a $137.5 million contract in the offseason based on last year’s perfect finish.
“We will show up tomorrow and we will be men about it,” Shanahan said. “… It is part of the NFL season and that is what you have to do. We all feel for Jimmy, there’s no doubt about it.”
When Garoppolo went down, left guard Laken Tomlinson said fear began to “creep in” and Staley hoped Garoppolo had sustained a concussion.
At the time of his injury, Garoppolo had thrown for 251 yards and two touchdowns and had the 49ers just 7 yards away from trimming a 28-point hole to a touchdown.
In reviewing the game, Staley noted the 49ers’ inability to play consistently well for four quarters this season.
“We’re really trying to take that next step,” he said. “We’re trying so effing hard to take that next step.”
Now, because of one disastrous step by Garoppolo, it’s appears quite possible the 49ers won’t be taking that next step in a season that just began.
September 23, 2018 at 8:43 pm in reply to: reporters on the Chargers game (articles, tweets, vids) #91263
znModeratorLindsey Thiry@LindseyThiry
Quarterback Jared Goff took command of the Rams’ offense in a 35-23 victory over the Chargers, completing passes to six playmakers and even scrambling for 16 yards of his own. The Rams’ offense has now posted 30-plus points in each of their three games, but as they prepare for a quick turnaround on Thursday night against the Minnesota Vikings, the biggest question is whether their star-studded defense will be ready after cornerbacks Marcus Peters and Aqib Talib left the game Sunday because of injuries.==
Joe Curley@vcsjoecurley
Sean McVay on Goff’s performance: “With the exception of the one great play by Derwin Jones down in the red zone, I thought Goff was excellent today. He demonstrated excellent command, responded series after series.”==
Rich Hammond@Rich_Hammond
Rams receiver Robert Woods, on Chargers fans and the “rivalry” feel of the game: “Coming out, they were kind of loud, but I think we quieted them up. At the end of the game, you knew whose house it was, who is L.A.’s team.”
znModeratorRich Hammond@Rich_Hammond
Rams’ JoJo Natson broke his hand today, so the search for a returner will be reopened.
znModeratorFinally up from #LARams locker room. McVay said both Talib/Peters have ankle injuries (I know, there’s been a lot of different things said about Peters’ injury, but that’s what we heard from McVay). Also returner JoJo Natson broke his hand and may require surgery.
— Myles Simmons (@MylesASimmons) September 24, 2018
September 23, 2018 at 8:39 pm in reply to: reporters on the Chargers game (articles, tweets, vids) #91260
znModeratorVincent Bonsignore@VinnyBonsignore
#Rams QB Jared Goff said he sensed a rivalry atmosphere on Sunday against the #Chargers in how the fans of both teams made their presence felt and heard at the Coliseum. (And I agree. It was a cool environment today. A good day for L.A. football)==
Just a System QB throw… 🤷🏻♂️ https://t.co/9LS4xKEtaR
— Andrew Whitworth (@awhitworth77) September 24, 2018
znModeratorMarcus Peters diagnosed with calf strain, will get MRI
Marcus Peters diagnosed with calf strain, will get MRI
When Rams cornerbac Marcus Peters was injured in the first half of Sunday’s victory over the Chargers, word on the CBS broadcast was that he was being tested for an Achilles injury.
An Achilles tear would have ended Peters’ season, but that’s not the diagnosis. PFT has learned, via a league source, that tests on Peters’ Achilles were negative.
Peters has been diagnosed with a calf strain and will have an MRI to determine the extent of the injury.
The Rams also saw cornerback Aqib Talib depart with an ankle injury during the 35-23 win. PFT has learned that he has a sprain and will undergo further evaluation on Monday.
The Rams are on a short week as they face the
September 23, 2018 at 8:15 pm in reply to: reporters on the Chargers game (articles, tweets, vids) #91254
znModeratorJoe Curley@vcsjoecurley
Director of Strength and Performance Ted Rath marching around the Rams locker room managing the recovery process for Thursday, “Let’s go. Minnesota starts now.”Rams have more than 10 massage tables in locker room as players begin recovery process for TNF
Sean McVay’s postgame presser halted by a fire alarm. How’s that for a metaphor for today at the Coliseum.
—
Ryan Kartje@Ryan_Kartje
Chargers cornerback Casey Hayward on Rams QB Jared Goff: “He’s the engine that makes it go.”==
J.B. Long@JB_Long
Jared Goff with another red zone pick in Week Three, but otherwise sensational.29/36 for 354 yds, 3TD
#LARams improve to 7-0 when QB1 throws for 300+.
==
Gary Klein@LATimesklein
Ndamukong Suh with his first sack for the Rams.==
J.B. Long@JB_Long
The #LARams have three double-digit wins, a +66 scoring differential.First time scoring 30+ points in first 3 games since 2000.
znModeratorGary Klein@LATimesklein
Talib has a crutch in his locker
znModeratorProFootballTalk@ProFootballTalk
Per source tests on CB Marcus Peters Achilles were negative. Calf strain. MRI coming.Rich Hammond@Rich_Hammond
I can confirm this. Still likely to be some time missed.Rich Hammond added,
ProFootballTalkSeptember 23, 2018 at 7:19 pm in reply to: reporters on the Chargers game (articles, tweets, vids) #91245
znModeratorRams put up 521 yards in 35-23 win
Rams put up 521 yards in 35-23 win
https://profootballtalk.nbcsports.com/2018/09/23/rams-put-up-523-yards-in-35-23-win/The Rams offense impressed in the first two weeks of the regular season and they outdid themselves in Week Three against the Chargers.
Jared Goff threw for 354 yards, Todd Gurley ran for 105 and the team piled up 521 yards while beating the Chargers 35-23 in the NFL’s first Battle of Los Angeles since 1994. That moves the Rams to 3-0 ahead of Thursday night’s game against the Vikings, who will be coming to L.A. off the back of getting their teeth kicked in by the previously winless Bills.
Goff and Gurley both had turnovers in the first half and it looked for a time like the game might develop into a shootout, but the Chargers opted to kick a field goal down 15 points in the fourth quarter and then failed to convert a fourth down after forcing the first Johnny Hekker punt of the game on the ensuing drive.
That made the result academic, but all the feelings won’t be ecstatic in the locker room after the game. Cornerbacks Marcus Peters and Aqib Talib both left the win with injuries and any extended absences would leave the Chargers vulnerable at a particularly important spot on their defense.
Word on the severity of those injuries will come in time. Answers to the Rams offense may be harder to find for opposing teams in the weeks and months to come.
September 23, 2018 at 7:18 pm in reply to: reporters on the Chargers game (articles, tweets, vids) #91244
znModerator¡Goff a Kupp para seis!#VamosRams pic.twitter.com/kPJ5aJLTOI
— Los Angeles Rams (@RamsNFL) September 23, 2018
znModerator.@TG3II puts the #LARams on the board! #LACvsLA pic.twitter.com/Q690MK052G
— Los Angeles Rams (@RamsNFL) September 23, 2018
znModerator.@robertwoods with his first touchdown of 2018! #LACvsLA pic.twitter.com/fUoepOMZ8U
— Los Angeles Rams (@RamsNFL) September 23, 2018
znModeratorCORY. LITTLETON.
Littleton with the punt block + @TheeCount2 with the touchdown! pic.twitter.com/pwxBBMNqxb
— Los Angeles Rams (@RamsNFL) September 23, 2018
znModeratorCostly win, but the offense looked so good.
znModeratorAll well reasoned.
September 23, 2018 at 10:47 am in reply to: Will the Rams somehow squeak by the 1-1 Chargers? #91218
znModeratorWith a name like Johnsonville, you know those Italian sausages have to be great.
Z and I are playing around but for anyone who might not know, his pic above and our discussion of it all allude to an old line we used to use about the GSOT Rams–that they would (quote) “smoke the league like sausage in a refinery fire.”
I take that as a line as immortal in its own, different way as things like “from these honored dead we take increased devotion to that cause for which they gave the last full measure of devotion” and “We shall fight on the beaches, we shall fight on the landing grounds, we shall fight in the fields and in the streets, we shall fight in the hills” and “all work and no play make Jack a dull boy.”
September 23, 2018 at 10:08 am in reply to: settin up Chargers game (posters, reporters, what LAC fans are saying, etc.) #91216
znModeratorSeptember 23, 2018 at 2:07 am in reply to: settin up Chargers game (posters, reporters, what LAC fans are saying, etc.) #91209
znModeratorAccording to two talent evaluators, the Rams have the clear advantage over the Chargers for now
Sam Farmer
LOS ANGELES—In a couple of years, they’ll share a stadium.
For now, they’ll share the stage.
The Los Angeles Rams and Los Angeles Chargers will play each other at the Coliseum on Sunday, meeting for the first time since their relocation to Los Angeles in a game that actually means something. Both are talented teams widely favored to win their respective divisions, and potentially make deep postseason runs.
So which team has the better roster?
For that, the Los Angeles Times turned to two personnel executives who work for uninvolved NFL teams to weigh in anonymously, position group by position group, on which players they would prefer. Each is a seasoned evaluator and, in the interest of clarity, we refer to them as Scouts 1 and 2.
On to the breakdown:
Quarterback
Both evaluators give the Chargers’ Philip Rivers the nod here, based on his years of experience. That’s not to suggest they don’t like Jared Goff, because they do, but the Rams’ quarterback has turned in one impressive season whereas the 36-year-old Rivers has been consistently good for more than a decade.
As Scout 1 said: “If you’re building a team and you’re a young team like the Rams, you obviously want Goff. But if you take the play caller out of it, take (Rams coach) Sean McVay out of it, and Goff has to call the game on the field by himself? I’m taking Philip Rivers. If the communication headset goes down, and you’re in a two-minute offense and everything’s going really fast, I’m taking Philip Rivers. But that’s not a knock on Goff. He might be that guy in a couple years.”
Scout 2: “Goff is going to be good. I don’t know if he’ll ever be as good as Rivers. Goff is in the perfect scheme with the perfect coach.”
Advantage: Chargers
Running back
No question here: It’s the Rams’ Todd Gurley over Melvin Gordon. That’s not surprising, considering Gurley is the defending NFL offensive player of the year, and the darling of every fantasy league.
“To me this one’s not close,” Scout 1 said. “I would take Gurley every day. I think Gordon’s good, but I think Gurley is special. From his explosiveness to his vision, he runs with power, he can catch the ball. He’s got breakaway speed in the open field. He’s the perfect back. He’s in the top three or four in the league.”
Advantage: Rams
Receivers
The Rams were the pick in this category, although each scout lavished praise on the receivers of both teams.
Scout 1 sees the Chargers’ Keenan Allen as a cut above the rest, an elite receiver, with Mike Williams as a rising star, but still feels the Rams’ combination of Robert Woods, Brandin Cooks and Cooper Kupp is more effective.
Scout 2 agrees: “They have one of everything. They have the deep vertical guy in Cooks, a good run-after-catch guy in Woods, and Kupp is a really quick possession guy in the slot.”
Neither scout is wowed by the tight ends: Virgil Green of the Chargers and Tyler Higbee of the Rams. Good but not great.
Advantage: Rams
Offensive line
Once again, the evaluators are on opposite sides of the fence, with Scout 1 giving the edge to the Rams and Scout 2 taking the Chargers. The scouts made positive mention of both Chargers tackles, Russell Okung and Joe Barksdale. Both lines got respectable but not phenomenal grades.
Scout 1 praised Rams left tackle Andrew Whitworth: “He’s the ultimate pro, a leader who has toughness. He’s the epitome of what an offensive lineman should be.”
Scout 2, who sees improvement in the Chargers line, said he’s waiting to see more from the Rams: “They have played some bad teams that haven’t gotten near Goff.”
Advantage: Split decision
Defensive line
Both are on the same page: Combine the Chargers edge rushers of Joey Bosa and Melvin Ingram with the Rams interior linemen of Aaron Donald and Ndamukong Suh, and you’d have the new-age Fearsome Foursome and then some.
There’s no debate between the evaluators that Donald, the 2017 defensive player of the year, is the brightest star of the group.
“He’s in the top three defensive players right now, with maybe (Denver’s) Von Miller and (Chicago’s) Khalil Mack,” Scout 2 said of Donald. “You just can’t block him one-on-one.”
Said Scout 1 of Donald: “It’s his leverage, his power, his quickness, his hand use. He can get skinny in the hole, he can play the power game. His whole pass-rush repertoire is unbelievable. If he continues at this level, he’s a Hall of Famer.”
When healthy, Bosa is a dominant force too.
“He’s strong, physical, gets upfield as a rusher. Bosa is a difference-maker,” Scout 1 said. “Ingram is quick off the ball, he can bend, good hand use, closing speed.”
Advantage: Rams interior linemen, Chargers edge rushers
Linebackers
This isn’t an apples-to-apples comparison, because when Wade Phillips was changing the Rams from a 4-3 scheme to a 3-4, the Chargers were transitioning the other way, from a 3-4 to a 4-3, under Gus Bradley. So the assignments are different.
“The one thing I’ve noticed about the Chargers is they’ve gotten a lot faster at the position,” Scout 1 said. “That’s something that Gus Bradley has really pushed. He loves speed at linebacker.”
Seeing as Bosa (currently injured) and Ingram line up as defensive ends for the Chargers, Scout 2 favored the Rams linebacking group that includes Mark Barron, Cory Littleton, Samson Ebukam, Dominique Easley and Matt Longacre by the slightest of margins.
Scout 1 likes the Chargers’ group that includes Denzel Perryman, Kyle Emanuel, Jatavis Brown and rookie Uchenna Nwosu.
Advantage: Split decision
Cornerbacks
This one was easy. The evaluators took the Rams’ combination of Aqib Talib and Marcus Peters over the Chargers’ Casey Hayward and Trevor Williams.
Scout 1: “I really like the playmaking ability of Marcus Peters, his ability to jump routes, his aggressiveness, lot of swagger and emotion on the field. He sees it quickly and is a big-time gambler but he knows when to take his shots. He and Aqib are very aggressive and similar, even though Peters is a lot younger.”
Advantage: Rams
Safeties
The scouts praised the Rams’ combination of John Johnson and Lamarcus Joyner, but give the edge to the Chargers in this department with Jahleel Addae, Rayshawn Jenkins and, in particular, rookie first-round pick Derwin James.
Advantage: Chargers
Special teams
Even with injuries to Rams kicker Greg Zuerlein and returner Pharoh Cooper, the scouts give the Rams the upper hand, largely because of the outstanding punting of Johnny Hekker and coaching of John Fassel.
Advantage: Rams
-
AuthorPosts

