I agree with most of that. But I like Reynold’s game more than you do, it appears.
Yes, he’s inconsistent, and that’s a problem. But, to me, he’s flashed real skilz at times, especially running after the catch. While he doesn’t always show this, he can run with a kind of violence that the other receivers lack. And he has height, which all but Kupp lack. To me, he’s a solid #3, and an excellent #4.
Cooks? We’ve discussed this before, and I think you and I are basically on the same page here. Though I may see him as more problematic on contested passes than you do. To me, he’s actually a liability in those situations. He almost never comes down with those passes, and this opens up more potential for interceptions, etc.
He does a lot of other things really, really well, and obviously has speed to burn. I just wish he could high point the football and come down with it. That would turn him into one of the best deep threats in the league. As it stands, he’s dangerous on deep routes, but only if he’s actually “open.”
IMO, the Rams should be looking for receivers who excel at those jump balls. They can be found even later in the draft, or in FA, without breaking the bank. They can’t be, of course, if they combine that skill set with others, pushing them into the #1 receiver type, etc.