“The Marxist cultural critic Walter Benjamin once argued that every rise of fascism bears witness to a failed revolution. Benjamin was not only addressing elements of a failed political revolution, but also the failure of language, values, courage, vision and a critical consciousness. In the midst of a moment when an older social order is crumbling and a new one is struggling to define itself, there is always a moment of confusion and danger. We have arrived at such a moment in which two worlds are colliding.
First, there is the harsh and crumbling world of neoliberal globalization and its mobilizing passions that fuel a US-style fascism. Second, there is a counter movement with its search for a new politics that can rethink, reclaim and invent a new understanding of democratic socialism, untainted by capitalism. In the midst of this struggle, a new political movement and social order will be born, though one without guarantees. Something sinister and horrifying is happening to liberal democracies all over the globe. The global architecture of democracy is giving way to authoritarian tyrannies. As alarming as the signs may be, we cannot look away and allow the terrors of the unforeseen to be given free rein. We cannot allow the power of dreams to turn into nightmares.
It is hard to imagine a more urgent moment for developing a language of critique and possibility that would serve to awaken our critical and imaginative senses and help free us from the tyrannical nightmare that has descended upon the United States under the rule of Donald Trump….see link…”
This kind of thing sets off all sorts of contradictory responses in me.
Yes a timely and spot-on critique would help.
But then those did exist in the 30s. Including of course Benjamin. They did no good whatsoever.
Part of a fascist environment is that critiques don’t matter. They’re just rendered irrelevant. “Benjamin doesn’t like us.” “That’s okay, when the time comes, we’ll just kill him.”
Fascism is driven by headstrong action. If it weren’t for that, it would just be a bunch of bad ideas on paper.
What matters against fascism is action, and that can take many forms, and is always better off being spontaneous and organic. I don’t care if the active people all agree on the perfect critique.
I like reading good critiques though. But to me they’re more for analytic clarity. If the various kinds and types of different activists never read any of it, that’s fine with me.
…
BTW there is no scene like this in any american ww 2 movie ever. Give it a listen and watch for when the main character in the scene mentions “fascism.” And notice the ethnic composition of the crowd around him. Which is historically accurate (this is set in Bastogne during the battle of the bulge).