My political rant of the day

Recent Forum Topics Forums The Public House My political rant of the day

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #106095
    waterfield
    Participant

    I can understand a divided country when you have “normal” Republicans battling “normal” democrats. We’ve always had close elections (i.e. Gore v Bush). What I don’t get is how at least 40% of the voting public can still stand by this authoritarian ruler who has clear disdain for our Constitution and the rule of law in the pursuit of his own personal objectives. What has happened to this huge segment of our population ?. In one sense I blame Hollywood-namely television and the movies-a solid bastion of liberality. With both The Sopranos and the Godfather trilogy we’ve made heroes out of the “bad” guys. I honestly think that these lock step followers of Trump (almost half the country) would have been very happy and comfortable living in Germany during the 1930s when the Nazis destroyed democracy, targeted minorities and political enemies, and encouraged conformity and consent within German society in order to build the Third Reich.

    #106096
    joemad
    Participant

    i think AM conservative talk radio with no fairness doctrine is more responsible than Tony Soprano and Vito Corleone….

    these guys on AM talk can spew any opinion they want without being challenged nor corrected….

    #106097
    wv
    Participant

    Fair enough, but once in a while sit back and ask yourself how bad the ‘normal Dems’ had to be, to push half the country towards Trump. I mean, why didnt the Dems appeal to these people?

    w
    v

    #106100
    waterfield
    Participant

    Fair enough, but once in a while sit back and ask yourself how bad the ‘normal Dems’ had to be, to push half the country towards Trump. I mean, why didnt the Dems appeal to these people?

    w
    v

    My answer to that is: It wasn’t the Democrats that pushed them it was ALL politicians including republicans. It was a revolt for these people. They wanted someone who didn’t talk, act, smell, like a politician. Simply put, they wanted someone like themselves. Same with Hitler.

    #106108
    wv
    Participant

    Fair enough, but once in a while sit back and ask yourself how bad the ‘normal Dems’ had to be, to push half the country towards Trump. I mean, why didnt the Dems appeal to these people?

    w
    v

    My answer to that is: It wasn’t the Democrats that pushed them it was ALL politicians including republicans. .

    ============

    Well, I dont think Trump voters are some monolithic block. You dont think that either, right.

    What you are describing sounds like the racist-nationalist part of his core. Maybe also the rightwing-evangelical-block but I’m not sure how many of them actually liked Trump.

    But he’s got other blocks. For example many of the West Virginians who voted for Trump, had previously voted for Obama. How do you explain that one? 🙂

    w
    v

    #106109
    Billy_T
    Participant

    In my view, people are attributing far too much to Trump himself, as far as his “base” is concerned. He inherited the vast majority of it, simply by being the GOP standard bearer. The same people who voted for Romney, McCain, Dubya, Bush Sr, etc. etc. voted for Trump. If they’re old enough, the same people who voted for Reagan, Nixon, Goldwater and so on.

    There’s no doubt in my mind that if Trump had run as an independent, he would have been crushed by the GOP nominee. If Kasich or Rubio, for instance, had won, they would have had at least as large a group of diehards behind them, if not larger.

    Trump, on his own, brings very few new people into the GOP, and he loses more than most would to the Dems.

    This is why I think the Dems make a huge mistake if they think the answer is to chase after Trump voters. They’re not going to vote Dem anyway. Smarter way to win in 2020? Go after the people who staid home who lean left. They’re virtually the only ones available in the “undecided” column.

    #106111
    Billy_T
    Participant

    WV,

    This is in dispute, of course, and it’s not an exact science. But several articles after the 2016 noted that far and away most of those “Obama to Trump” voters had previously voted Republican for their entire adult lives. As in, it wasn’t that they switched from the Dems to Trump. They switched from the GOP to Obama (first), and then back to Trump again.

    Also in dispute is what caused the switch, but I think that’s where your comment about the Dems driving people into the hands of the “populist right” comes in. This also was the case in Europe and in parts of Asia. The status quo, centrist, corporatist parties, in much of the world, pushed enough disillusioned voters over the line to lose them.

    Reverse engineer that, and the logical answer (to me) is that the next time left of center parties win, they need to go Big. Very big. Very bold. Seriously progressive. Or we’ll have other Trumps and Boris Johnsons, or worse to come.

    #106112
    Billy_T
    Participant

    Side note: Jack posted it earlier, but when I saw the article at the NYT, I was livid. Trump was told that it was illegal to just shoot migrants, which he called for. He wanted to do that. So he kept trying to figure out ways to end this manufactured border “crisis” that were legal, and was told, repeatedly, “No, Mr. President,” you can’t do that.” He changed to shooting them in the legs, electrifying the fence, putting flesh-ripping spikes on the top of the wall, adding moats with snakes and alligators in them.

    The man is a sadist and a monster.

    At this point, going back to the topic above, the main reason why he keeps his base gives support for some recent studies on levels of stubbornness in humans. Those right of center, ideologically, the studies showed, tend to dig in even more when they’re confronted with facts. As in, they cling even harder to their stances, if criticized. Left of center people tend to reassess and give up on older positions, if the facts warrant this.

    Obviously, these studies were about aggregate behavior, not individual. Exceptions galore exist and are assumed.

    #106114
    wv
    Participant

    WV,

    This is in dispute, of course, and it’s not an exact science. But several articles after the 2016 noted that far and away most of those “Obama to Trump” voters had previously voted Republican for their entire adult lives. As in, it wasn’t that they switched from the Dems to Trump. They switched from the GOP to Obama (first), and then back to Trump again.

    Also in dispute is what caused the switch, but I think that’s where your comment about the Dems driving people into the hands of the “populist right” comes in..

    ===================

    Yeah, I think thats true that many were Reps who switched to Obama, but it doesnt really change the issue. They ‘could’ have just stayed the course and voted for Hillary, who was essentially a continuation of Obama.
    But they rejected that totally.

    Somethin about the Dems just pissed em off, i guess 🙂

    ….Has any National American Politician ‘ever’ gotten people’s blood up
    as much as Donald Trump? Lincoln maybe?

    w
    v

    #106117
    Billy_T
    Participant

    ===================

    Yeah, I think thats true that many were Reps who switched to Obama, but it doesnt really change the issue. They ‘could’ have just stayed the course and voted for Hillary, who was essentially a continuation of Obama.
    But they rejected that totally.

    Somethin about the Dems just pissed em off, i guess 🙂

    ….Has any National American Politician ‘ever’ gotten people’s blood up
    as much as Donald Trump? Lincoln maybe?

    w
    v

    Just a guess, but I think it’s a good one: Obama is likeable. HRC isn’t. As mentioned before, most voters pick a team and stick with it. Those who don’t, typically vote on the basis of connection with the candidate. HRC was never good at that. She could maintain the Dem lifers, but not expand the tent. Obama could expand it.

    As for getting the blood up. Dubya did that for me when he was prez. I had a visceral reaction to just seeing him on the screen, or hearing him. He pizzed me off to no end. Now he seems tame in comparison with Trump.

    Another side note: Trump lies more than any previous politician that we know of, and he does so in public. I think this gave him and his admin cover to do all kinds of rotten shit behind the scenes, cuz we thought we’d know all about it, given Trump’s public lying. In recent days, we’ve learned that, for years, Trump, Giuliani, Pompeo, Pence and now Barr, have been busy trying to discredit the Russian interference story, to make HRC and the Dems the villains instead.

    Trump has managed, without our knowing it, to get much of the government to work for his personal benefit. Not since Nixon have we seen anything like this, and more will come out in the coming weeks and months.

    In short, Trump’s clown show of sorts masks his often successful attempt to manipulate the so-called “deep state” to his own advantage. All too many media types assumed it would be all out in the open, that he was too stupid and too ignorant to hide stuff, that his ego wouldn’t allow the secrecy needed. Looks like we’ve been way wrong for some time now.

    #106119
    nittany ram
    Moderator

    What you are describing sounds like the racist-nationalist part of his core. Maybe also the rightwing-evangelical-block but I’m not sure how many of them actually liked Trump.

    w
    v

    A venn diagram of racist nationalists vs right wing evangelicals would overlap. I think the circles would practically eclipse one another.

    Racism is the one thing every Trump block has in common – from the most extreme white supremacists to the desperate working class folks who have bought the lie that blacks are living large on public assistance, and that programs like Affirmative Action are keeping “decent hard-working Americans” jobless.

    Trump is their savior who’s going to restore the proper order.

Viewing 11 posts - 1 through 11 (of 11 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Comments are closed.